Application and comparison of large-scale solution-based DNA capture-enrichment methods on ancient DNA

Scientific Reports
María C Ávila-ArcosM Thomas P Gilbert


The development of second-generation sequencing technologies has greatly benefitted the field of ancient DNA (aDNA). Its application can be further exploited by the use of targeted capture-enrichment methods to overcome restrictions posed by low endogenous and contaminating DNA in ancient samples. We tested the performance of Agilent's SureSelect and Mycroarray's MySelect in-solution capture systems on Illumina sequencing libraries built from ancient maize to identify key factors influencing aDNA capture experiments. High levels of clonality as well as the presence of multiple-copy sequences in the capture targets led to biases in the data regardless of the capture method. Neither method consistently outperformed the other in terms of average target enrichment, and no obvious difference was observed either when two tiling designs were compared. In addition to demonstrating the plausibility of capturing aDNA from ancient plant material, our results also enable us to provide useful recommendations for those planning targeted-sequencing on aDNA.


May 2, 2001·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Michael HofreiterSvante Pääbo
Nov 6, 2007·Nature Genetics·Emily HodgesW Richard McCombie
May 20, 2009·Bioinformatics·Heng Li, Richard Durbin
Jun 10, 2009·Bioinformatics·Heng Li1000 Genome Project Data Processing Subgroup
Jul 18, 2009·Science·Adrian W BriggsSvante Pääbo
Oct 20, 2009·Genome Biology·Ryan TewheyKelly A Frazer
Dec 8, 2009·Science·Jean-Philippe Vielle-CalzadaAlfredo Herrera-Estrella
Dec 8, 2009·Science·Patrick S SchnableRichard K Wilson
May 8, 2010·Science·Hernán A BurbanoSvante Pääbo
Nov 26, 2010·PloS One·Tomislav MaricicSvante Pääbo


Mar 16, 2013·Nature Protocols·Marie-Theres Gansauge, Matthias Meyer
Jan 24, 2013·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Qiaomei FuSvante Pääbo
Jan 18, 2013·PloS One·Sarah L FordyceM Thomas P Gilbert
Feb 13, 2013·International Journal of Evolutionary Biology·Ross D E MacPhee, Alex D Greenwood
Aug 8, 2014·BioMed Research International·Umberto RosaniPaola Venier
Aug 19, 2014·Journal of Clinical Virology : the Official Publication of the Pan American Society for Clinical Virology·Dennis Tappe, David E Alquezar-Planas
Dec 10, 2014·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Clio Der SarkissianLudovic Orlando
Jan 6, 2016·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Kimberly R AndrewsPaul A Hohenlohe
Sep 25, 2015·Molecular Ecology Resources·Cristina GambaLudovic Orlando
May 1, 2015·Molecular Ecology Resources·Johanna L A PaijmansDaniel W Förster
Jun 19, 2012·Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution·Johanna L A PaijmansMichael Hofreiter
Jul 4, 2015·Molecular Ecology·Matthew R Jones, Jeffrey M Good
Sep 24, 2015·Molecular Ecology Resources·John E McCormackBrant C Faircloth
Apr 11, 2012·Molecular Ecology·Pierre TaberletEske Willerslev
Oct 15, 2013·Molecular Ecology·Ke BiCraig Moritz
Jun 10, 2015·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Ludovic OrlandoEske Willerslev
Feb 27, 2014·American Journal of Human Genetics·Meredith L CarpenterCarlos D Bustamante
Jan 1, 2015·Nature Plants·Rute R da FonsecaM Thomas P Gilbert
Sep 4, 2015·PloS One·Robert KingAndrew L Phillips
May 26, 2016·Molecular Ecology Resources·Evan McCartney-MelstadH Bradley Shaffer
Aug 3, 2016·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Camilla SpellerMichael Hofreiter
Aug 12, 2016·The Journal of Heredity·Kristina M CammenAmy M Van Cise
Aug 28, 2016·Molecular Ecology Resources·Diana I Cruz-DávalosLudovic Orlando
Dec 21, 2016·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Bastien LlamasLudovic Orlando
Jul 3, 2015·Scientific Reports·Andaine Seguin-OrlandoLudovic Orlando
Jun 14, 2017·GigaScience·Anna PhilipsMarek Figlerowicz
Jul 17, 2018·Molecular Ecology Resources·Taylor M WilcoxMichael K Schwartz
Dec 27, 2018·American Journal of Physical Anthropology·Kirsten A ZiesemerHannes Schroeder
May 2, 2018·Annual Review of Biochemistry·Enrico CappelliniEske Willerslev
May 2, 2017·Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics·Christina WarinnerJohannes Krause
Dec 10, 2014·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·M ParksD M Lambert
Nov 24, 2019·Molecular Ecology·Lindsey E FendersonBastien Llamas
Mar 3, 2020·Annual Review of Plant Biology·Logan KistlerNathan Wales
Aug 31, 2016·Topics in Current Chemistry·Stefania VaiDavid Caramelli
Apr 7, 2019·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Maria A SpyrouJohannes Krause
Jan 24, 2015·Genetica·François Pompanon, Sarah Samadi
Jul 10, 2019·Annual Review of Microbiology·Kirsten I BosJohannes Krause
Aug 16, 2018·BMC Genomics·Diana I Cruz-DávalosMaría C Ávila-Arcos
Sep 1, 2015·Methods in Ecology and Evolution·Min TangDouglas W Yu
Apr 11, 2017·PeerJ·Alexander Seitz, Kay Nieselt
Nov 20, 2020·Current Protocols in Plant Biology·Sergio M LatorreRafal M Gutaker
Feb 17, 2021·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Daniel KlingAndreas Tillmar

Related Concepts

Nested Polymerase Chain Reaction
Sequence Determinations, DNA
DNA, Plant
Zea mays
Laboratory Procedures
Gene Targeting
Research Study
cDNA Library
Molecular Genetic Technique

Related Feeds

Ancient DNA

Ancient DNA sequences are able to offer valuable insights into molecular evolutionary processes, but are notoriously difficult to analyze due to molecular damage and exogenous dna contamination. Discover the latest research on Ancient DNA here.