Asking the right questions in the right way: the need for a shift in research on psychological treatments for addiction

Addiction
Jim Orford

Abstract

To identify possible reasons for the disappointingly negative results of methodologically rigorous controlled trials of psychological treatments in the addictions field. A selective overview of the literature on addictive behaviour change. Eight failings of existing research are described: failing to account for the outcome equivalence paradox; neglecting relationships in favour of techniques; failing to integrate treatment research and research on unaided change; imposing an inappropriate time-scale on the change process; failing to take a systems or social network view; ignoring therapists' tacit theories; not including the patient's view; and displaying an ignorance of modern developments in the philosophy of science. Treatment research has been asking the wrong questions in the wrong way. Three necessary shifts in ways of conducting research are proposed: (i) the field should stop studying named techniques and focus instead on change processes; (ii) change processes should be studied within the broader, longer-acting systems of which treatment is part; and (iii) science in the field should be brought up to date by acknowledging a variety of sources of useful knowledge.

References

Apr 1, 1976·The British Journal of Psychiatry : the Journal of Mental Science·J OrfordS Guthrie
Mar 1, 1974·Psychosomatic Medicine·S Kiritz, R H Moos
Jul 1, 1996·American Journal of Public Health·L C SobellM B Sobell
May 1, 1997·Journal of Studies on Alcohol·K HumphreysC Cohen
Jan 8, 2000·Journal of Studies on Alcohol·G J ConnorsM R Frone
Jul 7, 2000·Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology·D J MartinM K Davis
Dec 8, 2000·American Journal of Community Psychology·A MulveyS Cahill
Jan 5, 2001·Alcohol and Alcoholism : International Journal of the Medical Council on Alcoholism·UNKNOWN UKATT Research Team
Feb 24, 2001·Journal of Studies on Alcohol·J A CunninghamA Koski-Jännes
Oct 24, 2001·Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment·W Fals-Stewart, G R Birchler
Jan 22, 2002·American Journal of Community Psychology·P G Foster-FishmanK Fahrbach
Jul 18, 2002·Addictive Behaviors·Alex CopelloUNKNOWN UKATT Research Team. United Kingdom Alcohol Treatment Trial
Jan 17, 2003·Journal of Studies on Alcohol·Jon MorgensternThomas I Morgan
May 14, 2003·American Journal of Community Psychology·Rudolf H Moos
May 27, 2003·Substance Abuse : Official Publication of the Association for Medical Education and Research in Substance Abuse·Samuel S GlazerDaniel S Keller
Jul 17, 2003·Journal of Postgraduate Medicine·N C Hepburn
Jul 23, 2003·Addiction·George E Vaillant
Oct 1, 2003·Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology·Paul C AmrheinLaura Fulcher
Jan 2, 2004·American Journal of Community Psychology·Denis O GrayCraig Blakely
Apr 6, 2004·Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment·Keith HumphreysRoger Weiss
Jul 13, 2004·Social Science & Medicine·Bruce BolamKate Gleeson
Mar 24, 2005·Addiction·Petra S MeierRichard F Heller
May 25, 2005·American Journal of Community Psychology·Robin L Miller, Marybeth Shinn
May 25, 2005·American Journal of Community Psychology·Chris Barker, Nancy Pistrang
May 25, 2005·American Journal of Community Psychology·Jacob Kraemer Tebes

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Jan 11, 2014·Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation·Hyunna Kim
Feb 1, 2012·Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology·Katie WitkiewitzBryan Hartzler
Jun 5, 2013·Social Work in Public Health·Thomas M Kelly, Dennis C Daley
Jan 17, 2009·Alcohol and Alcoholism : International Journal of the Medical Council on Alcoholism·Jim OrfordUNKNOWN UKATT Research Team
Feb 12, 2013·Alcohol and Alcoholism : International Journal of the Medical Council on Alcoholism·Harald KlingemannSonja Stutz
Nov 15, 2011·The Behavioral and Brain Sciences·Christian P Müller, Gunter Schumann
Aug 1, 2013·BMC Psychiatry·Ayna B JohansenDag K Wennesland
Apr 16, 2015·Psychology and Psychotherapy·Sarah A JonesGillian Tober
May 27, 2009·Addiction·Jim Orford
May 28, 2009·Addiction·David Marjot
Apr 17, 2008·Addiction·Jim Orford
Nov 19, 2009·Addiction·Harald KlingemannLinda C Sobell
May 9, 2012·International Journal of Mental Health Nursing·Daryle DeeringChristopher M A Frampton
Aug 17, 2010·Addiction·Peter M Miller, Joshua P Smith
Jul 30, 2014·Addiction·William R Miller, Theresa B Moyers
Aug 29, 2009·Addiction·Doug Sellman
Apr 17, 2010·Clinical Psychology : a Publication of the Division of Clinical Psychology of the American Psychological Association·Aaron Hogue
Jan 19, 2010·Addiction·Mark B Sobell, Linda C Sobell
Jul 18, 2015·Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy·Douglas L PolcinRachael Korcha
Jan 3, 2015·The International Journal on Drug Policy·Paula C G AlvesMark Ashworth
Sep 21, 2012·International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology·Gila ChenNatti Ronel
Jun 21, 2013·International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology·Natti Ronel, Dana Segev
Aug 9, 2017·International Journal of Mental Health Nursing·Åsa PriebeLennart Fredriksson
Dec 9, 2008·The Cancer Journal·Heather S L Jim, Paul B Jacobsen
May 27, 2009·Archives of Women's Mental Health·Kaniz GausiaJacques Oosthuizen
Aug 11, 2020·Substance Abuse Treatment, Prevention, and Policy·Mostafa Amini-RaraniMaryam Moeeni
Sep 15, 2020·Substance Abuse : Research and Treatment·Patrick J DillonManoj Sharma

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Addiction

This feed focuses mechanisms underlying addiction and addictive behaviour including heroin and opium dependence, alcohol intoxication, gambling, and tobacco addiction.