Comparing the effect of DSM-congruent traumas vs. DSM-incongruent stressors on PTSD symptoms: A meta-analytic review

Journal of Anxiety Disorders
Sadie E Larsen, Maria L Pacella

Abstract

Experts have long debated how to define the PTSD traumatic stressor criterion. Prior research demonstrates that PTSD symptoms (PTSS) sometimes stem from events that do not meet the DSM requirements for Criterion A (e.g., divorce, bereavement, illness). This meta-analysis of 22 studies examined whether PTSS differ for DSM-congruent criterion A1 traumatic events vs. DSM-incongruent events. The overall effect was significant, albeit small, suggesting that PTSS were greater for individuals who experienced a DSM-congruent event; heterogeneity analyses also indicated further exploration. Two significant moderators emerged: assessment of both A1 and A2 (vs. A1 alone) yielded a significant effect for higher PTSS following traumas vs. stressors. Likewise, self-report assessment of life threat (Criterion A1)-vs. rater or a priori assessment of A1-yielded a significant effect for higher PTSS following traumas. Our results indicate that higher levels of PTSS develop following traumas, and highlight important methodological moderators that may affect this relationship.

References

Jan 1, 1995·Journal of Traumatic Stress·D D BlakeT M Keane
Aug 1, 1996·Behaviour Research and Therapy·E B BlanchardC A Forneris
Apr 9, 2002·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Claudia Avina, William O'Donohue
May 11, 2002·Journal of Abnormal Psychology·Ayelet Meron RuscioTerence M Keane
Jul 13, 2002·Journal of Clinical Psychology·Paula P SchnurrNancy C Bernardy
Aug 13, 2002·Annual Review of Psychology·Richard J McNally
Sep 6, 2003·BMJ : British Medical Journal·Julian P T HigginsDouglas G Altman
Jun 2, 2005·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·Sari D GoldDenise M Sloan
Jun 2, 2005·The British Journal of Psychiatry : the Journal of Mental Science·Saskia S L MolJ André Knottnerus
Oct 31, 2006·Behavior Therapy·Joshua J Broman-FulksBenjamin E Saunders
Nov 15, 2006·Journal of Abnormal Psychology·Lilia M Cortina, Sheryl Pimlott Kubiak
Apr 13, 2007·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Frank W Weathers, Terence M Keane
Aug 2, 2007·The British Journal of Psychiatry : the Journal of Mental Science·Iris M EngelhardRichard J McNally
Mar 11, 2008·Clinical Psychology Review·Gerald M Rosen, Scott O Lilienfeld
May 31, 2008·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·Miranda Van HooffDaniel J Barnes
Aug 5, 2008·Behaviour Research and Therapy·Michele Bedard-Gilligan, Lori A Zoellner
Mar 25, 2009·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·Steven L LancasterBenjamin F Rodriguez
Aug 26, 2009·Rehabilitation Psychology·Terri A deRoon-CassiniPatricia Horn
Sep 11, 2009·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Dean G KilpatrickRon Acierno
Sep 11, 2009·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Chris R BrewinSandro Galea
Sep 24, 2009·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Patricia A Resick, Mark W Miller
May 15, 2010·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·Amy CameronVictoria Follette
Jul 17, 2010·AIDS Patient Care and STDs·Anthony C TheuninckStuart Gibson
Aug 31, 2010·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·R Nicholas CarletonGordon J G Asmundson
Nov 26, 2010·Psychological Bulletin·Michelle J Bovin, Brian P Marx
Feb 8, 2011·Behaviour Research and Therapy·Steven L LancasterRebecca Weston
Feb 25, 2011·Journal of Health Psychology·Crystal A Gabert-QuillenDouglas L Delahanty
Feb 7, 2012·Psychological Trauma : Theory, Research, Practice and Policy·Jennifer H WortmannDonald Edmondson
Mar 2, 2012·Journal of Trauma & Dissociation : the Official Journal of the International Society for the Study of Dissociation (ISSD)·Samantha L AndersPatricia A Frazier
Mar 10, 2012·The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry·Andrea L RobertsKarestan C Koenen
Dec 19, 2012·Journal of Anxiety Disorders·Maria L PacellaDouglas L Delahanty
May 29, 2013·Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings·Marit SijbrandijMiranda Olff
Aug 27, 2013·European Journal of Psychotraumatology·Eva VerlindenRamón J L Lindauer
Oct 8, 2013·World Psychiatry : Official Journal of the World Psychiatric Association (WPA)·Andreas MaerckerGeoffrey M Reed
Oct 24, 2013·Journal of Traumatic Stress·Dean G KilpatrickMatthew J Friedman
Jan 15, 2014·Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma·Edward J AlessiIlan H Meyer
May 12, 2015·Psychological Trauma : Theory, Research, Practice and Policy·Hector F MyersHonghu Liu

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Nov 12, 2016·International Journal of Law and Psychiatry·Gerald Young
Dec 7, 2016·Depression and Anxiety·Lukoye AtwoliUNKNOWN WHO World Mental Health Survey Collaborators
Apr 12, 2017·Anxiety, Stress, and Coping·Yvette Z SzaboJeffrey C Valentine
Oct 31, 2019·The British Journal of Psychiatry : the Journal of Mental Science·Andy P Siddaway
Jul 7, 2020·Psychodynamic Psychiatry·Ramona FimianiGeorge Silberschatz
Sep 21, 2019·The Western Journal of Emergency Medicine·Joseph A DeLuciaPaula Buchanan
Dec 7, 2018·Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Services·Batool TirgariMohammad Ebrahimpour
Jul 23, 2021·PloS One·Sarah K DominguezChristopher William Lee

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Anxiety Disorders

Discover the latest research on anxiety disorders including agoraphobia, panic disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and post-traumatic stress disorder here.

Related Papers

Journal of Family Psychology : JFP : Journal of the Division of Family Psychology of the American Psychological Association (Division 43)
Jessica E LambertJessica Holzer
The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry
Andrea L RobertsKarestan C Koenen
© 2021 Meta ULC. All rights reserved