Abstract
Consistent with human gambling behavior but contrary to optimal foraging theory, pigeons show a strong preference for an alternative with low probability and high payoff (a gambling-like alternative) over an alternative with a greater net payoff (Zentall & Stagner, Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 278, 1203-1208, 2011). In the present research, we asked whether humans would show suboptimal choice on a task involving choices with probabilities similar to those for pigeons. In Experiment 1, when we selected participants on the basis of their self-reported gambling activities, we found a significantly greater choice of the alternative involving low probability and high payoff (gambling-like alternative) than for a group that reported an absence of gambling activity. In Experiment 2, we found that when the inhibiting abilities of typical humans were impaired by a self-regulatory depletion manipulation, they were more likely to choose the gambling-like alternative. Taken together, the results suggest that this task is suitable for the comparative study of suboptimal decision-making behavior and the mechanisms that underlie it.
References
Sep 1, 1987·The American Journal of Psychiatry·H R Lesieur, S B Blume
May 26, 1998·Journal of Personality and Social Psychology·R F BaumeisterD M Tice
Feb 13, 1999·Journal of Experimental Psychology. Animal Behavior Processes·W T HerbransonC P Shimp
Sep 20, 2002·Clinical Psychology Review·Namrata Raylu, Tian P S Oei
Jan 1, 2003·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Walter T HerbransonCharles P Shimp
Jul 23, 2003·Journal of Personality and Social Psychology·Brandon J SchmeichelRoy F Baumeister
Apr 23, 2005·Behavioural Processes·Carla H Lagorio, Gregory J Madden
Dec 16, 2006·Journal of Gambling Studies·Gregory J MaddenCarla H Lagorio
Sep 27, 1974·Science·A Tversky, D Kahneman
Dec 4, 2008·Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin·C Nathan DewallJon K Maner
Jun 2, 2009·Biological Psychiatry·Marion RivalanFrançoise Dellu-Hagedorn
Jul 28, 2009·Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews·Ruth J van HolstAnna E Goudriaan
Oct 10, 2009·Learning & Behavior·Cassandra D GipsonThomas R Zentall
Feb 24, 2010·Journal of Comparative Psychology·Walter T Herbranson, Julia Schroeder
Apr 29, 2010·Psychological Science·Holly C MillerThomas R Zentall
Jun 17, 2010·Psychonomic Bulletin & Review·Jessica P Stagner, Thomas R Zentall
Oct 15, 2010·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Thomas R Zentall, Jessica Stagner
Nov 3, 2010·Critical Care Medicine·Claire J CreutzfeldtDavid L Tirschwell
Jan 11, 2011·Behavioural Processes·Thomas R Zentall
Jan 26, 2011·Learning & Behavior·Rebecca M Rayburn-ReevesThomas R Zentall
Oct 13, 2011·Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences·Roy F Baumeister
Citations
Dec 12, 2012·Animal Cognition·Kristina F PattisonThomas R Zentall
Mar 31, 2012·Psychonomic Bulletin & Review·Holly C MillerThomas R Zentall
Jun 27, 2012·Psychonomic Bulletin & Review·Jennifer R LaudeThomas R Zentall
Apr 3, 2014·Behavioural Processes·Thomas R Zentall
Jan 20, 2016·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Margaret A McDevittElliot A Ludvig
Dec 18, 2015·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Jeffrey M PisklakMarcia L Spetch
Nov 13, 2014·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Howard RachlinMing Yen
Jul 23, 2015·Behavioural Processes·R Emmanuel Trujano, Vladimir Orduña
Dec 3, 2013·Behavioural Processes·Thomas R Zentall
Mar 19, 2014·Behavioural Brain Research·Mike J F RobinsonKent C Berridge
Sep 7, 2014·Behavioural Processes·Thomas R Zentall
Apr 22, 2016·ELife·Kiyohito IigayaPeter Dayan
Jul 17, 2016·Behavioural Processes·R Emmanuel TrujanoVladimir Orduña
Jul 22, 2016·PloS One·Aaron P SmithThomas R Zentall
Jan 20, 2017·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Jay E HinnenkampGregory J Madden
Apr 16, 2018·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Vikki J BlandChristopher A Podlesnik
Feb 20, 2018·Psychopharmacology·Aaron P SmithJoshua S Beckmann
Jun 22, 2018·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Vikki J BlandChristopher A Podlesnik
Dec 21, 2018·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Jeffrey M PisklakMarcia L Spetch
Aug 21, 2019·Learning & Behavior·Margaret A McDevittMalvina O Pietrzykowski
Jul 7, 2019·Scientific Reports·Lina KoppelGustav Tinghög
Jan 31, 2020·Learning & Behavior·Travis R Smith, Michael J Beran
Aug 28, 2020·Frontiers in Psychology·Jessica P StagnerKent D Bodily
Jul 28, 2017·Scientific Reports·Aaron P SmithThomas R Zentall
Nov 16, 2018·Animal Cognition·Thomas R ZentallJacob P Case
Apr 20, 2017·Learning & Behavior·Travis R SmithMichael E Young
Jan 19, 2021·Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior·Valeria V GonzálezMarco Vasconcelos