Detecting the number of clusters of individuals using the software STRUCTURE: a simulation study

Molecular Ecology
G EvannoJ Goudet

Abstract

The identification of genetically homogeneous groups of individuals is a long standing issue in population genetics. A recent Bayesian algorithm implemented in the software STRUCTURE allows the identification of such groups. However, the ability of this algorithm to detect the true number of clusters (K) in a sample of individuals when patterns of dispersal among populations are not homogeneous has not been tested. The goal of this study is to carry out such tests, using various dispersal scenarios from data generated with an individual-based model. We found that in most cases the estimated 'log probability of data' does not provide a correct estimation of the number of clusters, K. However, using an ad hoc statistic DeltaK based on the rate of change in the log probability of data between successive K values, we found that STRUCTURE accurately detects the uppermost hierarchical level of structure for the scenarios we tested. As might be expected, the results are sensitive to the type of genetic marker used (AFLP vs. microsatellite), the number of loci scored, the number of populations sampled, and the number of individuals typed in each sample.

References

Nov 11, 1995·Nucleic Acids Research·P VosM Kuiper
Jun 1, 1995·Molecular Ecology·D PaetkauC Strobeck
Aug 19, 1997·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·B Rannala, J L Mountain
Apr 12, 2001·Molecular Ecology·M BeaumontMichael W Bruford
May 1, 2001·Evolution; International Journal of Organic Evolution·Eric J PetitJérôme Goudet
Jul 12, 2001·The Journal of Heredity·François Balloux
Feb 22, 2002·Theoretical Population Biology·J K Pritchard, Peter Donnelly
Oct 31, 2002·Molecular Ecology·Claudio CiofiJeffrey R Powell
Aug 2, 2003·Human Heredity·Rust Turakulov, Simon Easteal
Nov 25, 2003·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Gordon LuikartPierre Taberlet
Feb 12, 2004·Molecular Ecology·Oliver BerryS D Sarre
Feb 18, 2005·Journal of Evolutionary Biology·S TrouveJ Goudet
Oct 1, 1996·Trends in Ecology & Evolution·P Jarne, P J Lagoda
Apr 1, 1997·Evolution; International Journal of Organic Evolution·Michel ChapuisatLaurent Keller

Citations

Aug 24, 2007·Die Naturwissenschaften·Camilla Ryne, Staffan Bensch
Mar 16, 2012·Die Naturwissenschaften·C RutzRobert C Fleischer
Feb 3, 2006·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Karl J SchmidThomas Altmann
Oct 19, 2006·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Cédric MariacYves Vigouroux
Jan 15, 2008·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Andrea MazzucatoFabio Veronesi
May 28, 2008·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Ibrahima OumarYves Vigouroux
Oct 3, 2008·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Silke StrackeHans-Peter Piepho
Jan 9, 2009·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Myounghai Kwak, Paul Gepts
Jul 30, 2009·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Verónica V LiaViviana A Confalonieri
Aug 4, 2009·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Dongling ZhangZichao Li
Aug 12, 2009·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Sandra FischerJ C Reif
Sep 17, 2009·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Aniko HorvathFrancois Balfourier
Jan 12, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·M DeuGilles Bezançon
Mar 31, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Muhammet SakiroğluE Charles Brummer
Mar 30, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Xiaohong YangJiansheng Li
Apr 23, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Jérémy ClotaultDidier Peltier
May 27, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Marília Lobo BurlePaul Gepts
Jun 23, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·L F de Alencar FigueiredoB Courtois
Jun 19, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·C Y HaoFrancois Balfourier
Nov 26, 2010·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Juan E ZalapaMichael D Casler
Jan 12, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Sofiane MezmoukBrigitte Mangin
Jan 19, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·E L HowardA Koutoulis
Feb 1, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·G SpataroValeria Negri
Jun 4, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Jennifer R MandelJohn M Burke
Jul 12, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Kenji Fujino, Natsuko Iwata
Aug 4, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Fabrice SagnardPierre C Sibiry Traoré
Aug 9, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Ming Li WangJianming Yu
Aug 19, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Anja BusBenjamin Stich
Sep 8, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Hongyun WangGary J Muehlbauer
Sep 29, 2011·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Zhuxi JiangBao-Rong Lu
Mar 14, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Monica RodriguezGiovanna Attene
Mar 16, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Ismail Yusuf RabbiMorag Ferguson
Mar 23, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Yingjie XiaoKede Liu
Mar 29, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Muhammad Javed IqbalHarbans L Bhardwaj
Aug 1, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Karin FiedlerRalf Uptmoor
Nov 6, 2012·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Matthew BlairDoug R Cook
Feb 6, 2013·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Cristina EsterasBelén Picó
Feb 26, 2013·TAG. Theoretical and applied genetics. Theoretische und angewandte Genetik·Elena CadicPatrick Vincourt
Mar 25, 2011·Microbial Ecology·Margaret M Koopman, Bryan C Carstens
Dec 26, 2009·Journal of Plant Research·Takanori YoshidaHidenori Tachida
Jun 9, 2012·Journal of Plant Research·Lua Lopez, Rodolfo Barreiro
Oct 13, 2009·Primates; Journal of Primatology·Vololoniaina R RazakamaharavoRick A Brenneman
Mar 11, 2010·Genetica·Mallikarjuna K AradhyaAnne Koehmstedt
Sep 10, 2011·Genetica·Xiaohong YangJianbing Yan
Nov 23, 2011·Genetica·Harvey D BlackburnSamuel Rezende Paiva
Sep 24, 2013·Genetica·José Marcelo Soriano VianaGeísa Pinheiro Paes
Jan 15, 2014·Plant Molecular Biology Reporter·Braulio J Soto-Cerda, Sylvie Cloutier
Dec 17, 2009·Forensic Science, Medicine, and Pathology·E A AlacsJ Robertson
Jun 22, 2012·Bulletin of Entomological Research·Tolulope A AgunbiadeBarry R Pittendrigh
May 9, 2012·Bulletin of Entomological Research·A J JohnsonR H Shukle
Mar 2, 2013·Bulletin of Entomological Research·Juan Antonio SanchezFernando Cánovas
Mar 23, 2012·Animal : an International Journal of Animal Bioscience·J M PrystupaY Plante
Mar 23, 2012·Animal : an International Journal of Animal Bioscience·R BozziF Goyache
Jun 25, 2009·European Journal of Human Genetics : EJHG·Vincenza ColonnaMarina Ciullo
Dec 25, 2008·Heredity·N E ZygouridisK D Mathiopoulos
Oct 2, 2008·Heredity·M X WangZ C Li
Nov 17, 2011·Heredity·Guillermo Velo-AntónAdolfo Cordero-Rivera
Oct 3, 2013·Heredity·J A M BertrandChristophe Thebaud
Nov 29, 2007·The ISME Journal·Nicole M Gerardo, Eric J Caldera
Jul 24, 2012·Nature Biotechnology·Andrea L HarperIan Bancroft
Dec 8, 2011·Nature Communications·Sébastien J PuechmailleEmma C Teeling
Aug 23, 2006·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Laurent Excoffier, Gerald Heckel
Jul 29, 2008·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·David B McDonaldFrank J Rahel
Jun 3, 2008·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Junhui DuanLouis Miller
Jan 7, 2009·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Gabriele GentileValerio Sbordoni
Apr 22, 2009·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Jean PeccoudJean-Christophe Simon
Apr 7, 2010·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Jonna KulmuniPekka Pamilo
Mar 16, 2011·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Brad Oberle, Barbara A Schaal
Feb 2, 2011·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Karolina HärnströmAnna Godhe
Mar 4, 2011·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Mary Katherine GonderSarah A Tishkoff
Dec 29, 2011·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Erhan YalcindagFranck Prugnolle
Sep 6, 2012·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Michael C FontaineFréderic Austerlitz
Oct 4, 2012·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Fei DaiGuoping Zhang
Mar 27, 2013·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Emily Jane McTavishDavid M Hillis
Oct 2, 2013·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Sean W CorleyJennifer M Seddon
Sep 12, 2013·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Luis BarbozaRubén Alcázar
Mar 6, 2013·Foodborne Pathogens and Disease·Vincenzo SpanuEnrico Pietro Luigi De Santis
Apr 6, 2012·AoB Plants·Melissa Oliveira Santos-GarciaAnete Pereira Souza
Feb 26, 2008·Bioinformatics·Yu Zhang
Jul 4, 2009·Bioinformatics·Eric DurandOlivier François
Aug 2, 2013·DNA Research : an International Journal for Rapid Publication of Reports on Genes and Genomes·Kenta ShirasawaSatoshi Tabata
Apr 9, 2013·Genome Biology and Evolution·Shuzhen LiGang Yang
Dec 12, 2012·The Journal of Infectious Diseases·Jennifer K MeeceKurt D Reed
May 13, 2008·The Journal of Heredity·Gabriel J ColbeckMichael S Webster
Oct 7, 2008·The Journal of Heredity·Jennifer I SchmidtKevin G McCracken
Jun 6, 2009·The Journal of Heredity·Carol J Baskauf, John M Burke
Dec 8, 2009·The Journal of Heredity·Catarina GinjaM Cecilia T Penedo
Mar 17, 2010·The Journal of Heredity·Danielle A FariaDario Grattapaglia
Aug 20, 2010·The Journal of Heredity·Joseph I HoffmanAndrew Clarke
Sep 2, 2010·The Journal of Heredity·Oliver BalmerAdalgisa Caccone
Sep 24, 2010·The Journal of Heredity·Jessica StapleyJon Slate
May 31, 2011·The Journal of Heredity·Aaron W SchreyHenry R Mushinsky
Jul 23, 2011·The Journal of Heredity·Yanni WangXinrong Wan
Aug 4, 2011·The Journal of Heredity·Sophie LaurenceAlbrecht I Schulte-Hostedde
Sep 6, 2011·The Journal of Heredity·Justin B LackRonald A Van Den Bussche
Feb 10, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Natalie D HalbertJames N Derr
May 9, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Nora H OleasJavier Francisco-Ortega
May 23, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Pierre Duchesne, Julie Turgeon
Jul 28, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Serina FillerGottfried Brem
Aug 11, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Gordana Rasic, Nusha Keyghobadi
Sep 5, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Hermilo Sánchez-SánchezKen Oyama
Aug 17, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Patrick G Meirmans
Nov 6, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Charlyn PartridgeAdam G Jones
Oct 23, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Melody PorlierAnne Charmantier
Oct 24, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Sílvia Pérez-EsponaJosephine M Pemberton
Nov 6, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Matthew A Cronin, Michael D MacNeil
Dec 12, 2012·The Journal of Heredity·Tali Magory CohenGila Kahila Bar-Gal
Jan 18, 2013·The Journal of Heredity·Andres AguilarMatthew O Goldsworthy
Mar 15, 2013·The Journal of Heredity·Scott D GevaertLisa A Donovan
May 18, 2013·The Journal of Heredity·David T GauthierJens Carlsson
Jul 31, 2013·The Journal of Heredity·Zhou FangPeter L Morrell
Oct 17, 2013·The Journal of Heredity·Vincent P RichardsJose V Lopez
Apr 4, 2008·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Deirdre A JoyXin-zhuan Su
May 23, 2009·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Eric DurandOlivier François
Jun 19, 2009·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Oscar RamírezM Amills
Jan 5, 2011·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Jeremiah W BuschDaniel J Schoen
Jun 18, 2011·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Manuela SironiMario Clerici
Jan 1, 2013·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Yong-Hwee E LohJ Todd Streelman
Oct 1, 2013·Molecular Biology and Evolution·Mark A ChapmanDmitry A Filatov
Nov 4, 2011·Molecular Plant-microbe Interactions : MPMI·Silke Werth, Christoph Scheidegger
Aug 19, 2011·Phytopathology·Simone Prospero, Daniel Rigling
Aug 4, 2012·Phytopathology·Z K AtallahK V Subbarao
Aug 30, 2007·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Borja MiláThomas B Smith
Aug 30, 2007·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Charles D CriscioneTimothy J C Anderson
Feb 7, 2008·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Andrew B MunkacsiGeorgiana May
May 8, 2008·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Knut H RøedCarles Vilà
Apr 15, 2009·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Karl L EvansBen J Hatchwell
Aug 28, 2009·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Annika M E NoreenMadeleine J H van Oppen
Aug 21, 2009·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Shiang-Fan ChenStephen J Rossiter
Jun 18, 2010·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Alice CiboisEric Pasquet
May 20, 2011·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Silvia CasabiancaCristiano Vernesi
Sep 6, 2013·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Cheryl A Pinzone, Kelly A Dyer
Dec 18, 2013·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Jennifer N BoulayIliana B Baums
Nov 15, 2013·Proceedings. Biological Sciences·Hugo DarrasSerge Aron
Jun 27, 2008·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Roger S ThorpeHelena Johansson
Mar 3, 2010·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Sonya M Clegg, Albert B Phillimore
Mar 3, 2010·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Luis Fernando de LeónAndrew P Hendry
Feb 15, 2011·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·Helvecio D Coletta-FilhoRodrigo P P Almeida
Apr 22, 2008·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·Rodrigo P P AlmeidaJoao R S Lopes
Aug 3, 2012·Journal of Clinical Microbiology·Denise C CorneliusJohn C Meade
Apr 17, 2009·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Carmine GuarinoGuido Cipriani
Sep 22, 2009·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·P MusoliThierry Leroy
Apr 16, 2011·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Santiago Pereira-LorenzoTeresa Barreneche
May 4, 2011·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Muge Sayar-TuretLesley A Boyd
Jul 23, 2011·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Silvia NicolèGianni Barcaccia
Oct 18, 2011·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Yi-Hong WangKarl H Hasenstein
Oct 25, 2011·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·P SomtaP Srinives
Jun 12, 2012·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Hari D UpadhyayaSube Singh
Sep 8, 2012·Genome Génome / Conseil National De Recherches Canada·Josef PatzakJiří Sedlák
Nov 11, 2009·Genetics, Selection, Evolution : GSE·Silvia T Rodríguez-RamiloJesús Fernández
Jun 15, 2010·Genetics, Selection, Evolution : GSE·Catarina GinjaAlfredo Cravador
May 25, 2012·Genetics, Selection, Evolution : GSE·Jean-François DumasyPhilippe V Baret
Jan 16, 2010·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Andrea Blanquer, Maria J Uriz
Aug 27, 2010·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Liliana MilaniMarco Passamonti
Dec 15, 2010·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Rosa AgudoJosé Antonio Donázar
Jul 20, 2011·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Rosa A Sánchez-GuillénBengt Hansson
Oct 13, 2011·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Andreas HapkeOliver Zupke
Feb 12, 2011·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Mirjam M J JacobsBen Vosman
Aug 2, 2012·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Benjamin M Fitzpatrick
Oct 20, 2012·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Ivania Cerón-SouzaFrank Andrew Jones
Dec 12, 2012·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Maria Tereza C ThoméJoão Alexandrino
Jan 25, 2012·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Martina BradicRichard L Borowsky
Aug 14, 2013·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Jing RenJunhua Peng
Sep 7, 2013·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Emilie DumasOlivier Duron
Oct 29, 2013·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Matthias MarkolfPeter M Kappeler
Nov 19, 2013·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Pilar A Haye, Natalia C Muñoz-Herrera
Jul 31, 2008·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Arne LudwigShuichi Matsumura
Jan 30, 2008·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Susanne BjörnerfeldtCarles Vilà
Dec 2, 2008·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Nathalia GiraldoMauricio Linares
May 22, 2009·BMC Evolutionary Biology·Heidi M MeudtDavid Bryant
Nov 1, 2013·BMC Genetics·Juan Manuel Herrero-MedranoRichard P M A Crooijmans
Dec 10, 2013·BMC Genetics·Mohamed AlburakiLionel Garnery
Sep 18, 2013·BMC Genetics·Xiong-wei LiMaria Jose Aranzana
May 27, 2010·BMC Genomics·Javier GayánManuel Serrano-Ríos
Feb 15, 2012·BMC Genomics·Agnieszka NiedzielaAndrzej Anioł
Dec 19, 2012·BMC Microbiology·Vincent P RichardsMichael J Stanhope
Nov 11, 2010·BMC Plant Biology·Francesco EmanuelliM Stella Grando
Jun 20, 2012·BMC Plant Biology·Corina M FusariNorma B Paniego
Oct 8, 2013·BMC Plant Biology·Summaira RiazM Andrew Walker
Feb 12, 2013·BMC Plant Biology·Roberto BacilieriJean-Michel Boursiquot
Mar 19, 2013·BMC Plant Biology·Onildo Nunes de JesusAntonio Figueira
Oct 8, 2013·Malaria Journal·Nerea LarrañagaGustavo A Fontecha
Oct 17, 2007·Malaria Journal·Marta MorenoAgustín Benito
Jul 8, 2008·Malaria Journal·Christophe Antonio-NkondjioFrédéric Simard
Jun 15, 2010·Malaria Journal·Cyrille NdoFrédéric Simard
Apr 24, 2013·BMC Veterinary Research·Jennifer L AndersonJennifer K Meece
Jun 30, 2011·Parasites & Vectors·Johnson O OumaAdalgisa Caccone
Aug 15, 2009·PLoS Genetics·Samrat MondolUma Ramakrishnan
Aug 11, 2011·PLoS Genetics·Xavier DidelotPeter Donnelly
Apr 5, 2013·PLoS Genetics·Jennifer R MandelJohn M Burke
Mar 29, 2014·PLoS Genetics·Jared E DeckerJeremy F Taylor
Jul 10, 2008·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Katrin KuhlsGabriele Schönian
Mar 20, 2010·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Jon S BeadellAdalgisa Caccone
Nov 13, 2010·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Aurélien MercierMarie-Laure Dardé
Dec 24, 2010·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Sofía Ocaña-MayorgaMario J Grijalva
Feb 25, 2011·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Oliver BalmerAdalgisa Caccone
Aug 23, 2011·PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases·Naomi A DyerMartin J Donnelly
Oct 15, 2008·PloS One·Madeleine J H van OppenStuart Kininmonth
Apr 3, 2010·PloS One·David W WeisrockAnne D Yoder
Dec 15, 2010·PloS One·Yan-Fei ZengDa-Yong Zhang
Dec 24, 2010·PloS One·Martin MendezPablo Bordino
Mar 23, 2011·PloS One·Hai-Yan LüYuan-Ming Zhang
Jun 23, 2011·PloS One·Fernanda F CaniatoJurandir V Magalhaes
Sep 21, 2011·PloS One·José Martin PujolarAlain J Crivelli
Oct 8, 2011·PloS One·Kathrin LangenTimo Thünken
Nov 5, 2011·PloS One·Kristen Harfmann Short, Kenneth Petren
Jan 13, 2012·PloS One·Eleni BachlavaSteven J Knapp
Jun 6, 2012·PloS One·Li LuYongzhong Xing
Apr 4, 2012·PloS One·Mathieu Chouteau, Bernard Angers
Jun 16, 2012·PloS One·Ines Sanchez-DonosoJosé Domingo Rodríguez-Teijeiro