Abstract
In this article we propose a mitigation approach in those capital murder cases where traditional mitigation themes such as mental illness or low IQ are not present. To avoid prosecution characterization of these defendants as simply evil or antisocial personalities, we suggest reframing the issue as one of moral incompetence, based not on character defect but rather stemming from profoundly neglectful or abusive parenting. Under this reframing, defense teams would present evidence about the many antecedents of poor moral competence, its origins in neglect or abuse, its neurophysiological basis, and, most importantly, its potential for change. Evaluation in such cases would pay close attention to early childhood and family characteristics. We also recommend presentation of research findings showing how moral competence can be improved in adulthood, given appropriate guidance and support. This approach to mitigation is consistent with much of the developmental literature. But juror responses to these mitigation themes are as yet unknown.
References
Nov 9, 2001·Psychological Review·J Haidt
Sep 23, 2003·Behavioral Sciences & the Law·Bertram F Malle, Sarah E Nelson
Nov 29, 2005·European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience·Robert F AndaWayne H Giles
Sep 7, 2006·Annual Review of Psychology·June Price TangneyDebra J Mashek
May 19, 2007·Science·Jonathan Haidt
Apr 22, 2008·Development and Psychopathology·Candice L OdgersAvshalom Caspi
Nov 19, 2008·Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience·Kristin PrehnHauke R Heekeren
Jan 24, 2009·European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry·Julia Kim-CohenTerrie E Moffitt
Nov 13, 2010·The Neuroscientist : a Review Journal Bringing Neurobiology, Neurology and Psychiatry·Simone G Shamay-Tsoory
Jul 12, 2011·Criminal Justice and Behavior·June P TangneyMark Hastings
Jul 19, 2011·Neuropsychologia·Jean Decety, Eric C Porges
Dec 14, 2011·Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics : CQ : the International Journal of Healthcare Ethics Committees·Diana Harris
Mar 1, 2012·Behavioral Sciences & the Law·John F Edens, Jennifer Cox
May 27, 2015·Law and Human Behavior·Andrew SpiceStephen D Hart
Jun 4, 2015·PloS One·Kristin PrehnDiana C Robertson
Aug 11, 2015·The British Journal of Developmental Psychology·Ermanno Quadrelli, Chiara Turati
Aug 28, 2015·Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology·Rene CarbonneauRichard E Tremblay
Sep 2, 2015·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Jason M Cowell, Jean Decety
Sep 15, 2015·Behavioral Sciences & the Law·Armon J Tamatea
Dec 18, 2015·JAMA Psychiatry·Joan L LubyDeanna M Barch
Dec 25, 2015·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Grit HeinPhilippe N Tobler
Jun 22, 2016·Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology·Julia Rachel S E MazzaSylvana M Côté
Aug 17, 2016·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Patricia L LockwoodJonathan P Roiser
Nov 13, 2016·European Journal of Psychotraumatology·Anthony NazarovMargaret C McKinnon