Do humans optimally exploit redundancy to control step variability in walking?

PLoS Computational Biology
Jonathan B DingwellJoseph P Cusumano

Abstract

It is widely accepted that humans and animals minimize energetic cost while walking. While such principles predict average behavior, they do not explain the variability observed in walking. For robust performance, walking movements must adapt at each step, not just on average. Here, we propose an analytical framework that reconciles issues of optimality, redundancy, and stochasticity. For human treadmill walking, we defined a goal function to formulate a precise mathematical definition of one possible control strategy: maintain constant speed at each stride. We recorded stride times and stride lengths from healthy subjects walking at five speeds. The specified goal function yielded a decomposition of stride-to-stride variations into new gait variables explicitly related to achieving the hypothesized strategy. Subjects exhibited greatly decreased variability for goal-relevant gait fluctuations directly related to achieving this strategy, but far greater variability for goal-irrelevant fluctuations. More importantly, humans immediately corrected goal-relevant deviations at each successive stride, while allowing goal-irrelevant deviations to persist across multiple strides. To demonstrate that this was not the only strategy people...Continue Reading

Associated Datasets

References

Mar 12, 1992·Nature·C K PengH E Stanley
Oct 29, 1992·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·R M Alexander
Jan 1, 1974·European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology·M Y ZarrughH J Ralston
Jan 1, 1967·The British Journal of Radiology·I Williams
Jan 1, 1995·Journal of Applied Physiology·J M HausdorffA L Goldberger
Mar 1, 1995·Journal of Biomechanics·J J Collins
Jul 1, 1994·Integrative Physiological and Behavioral Science : the Official Journal of the Pavlovian Society·C K PengA L Goldberger
May 1, 1996·Journal of Applied Physiology·J M HausdorffA L Goldberger
Oct 31, 1996·Nature·P CordoF Moss
Jan 1, 1997·Journal of Applied Physiology·J M HausdorffA L Goldberger
Jun 21, 1997·Journal of Theoretical Biology·A E Minetti, R M Alexander
Jun 5, 1998·Movement Disorders : Official Journal of the Movement Disorder Society·J M HausdorffA L Goldberger
Sep 2, 1998·Nature·C M Harris, D M Wolpert
Apr 14, 1999·Gait & Posture·J Duysens, Van de Crommert HW
May 25, 1999·Progress in Neurobiology·E P Zehr, R B Stein
Oct 28, 1999·Nature·M GolubitskyJ J Collins
Jul 21, 2000·Nature Neuroscience·B A Reddi, R H Carpenter
Feb 15, 2001·Nature Neuroscience·W H WarrenS Sahuc
Mar 30, 2001·Journal of Biomechanical Engineering·J B DingwellD Sternad
Apr 26, 2001·Journal of Theoretical Biology·J E Bertram, A Ruina
Jun 13, 2001·Journal of Mathematical Psychology·Sascha E. Engelbrecht
Jul 31, 2001·Journal of Biomechanical Engineering·A D Kuo
Aug 10, 2001·Journal of Neurophysiology·R A ScheidtF A Mussa-Ivaldi
Oct 17, 2001·Journal of Biomechanical Engineering·F C Anderson, M G Pandy
Jan 11, 2002·Physical Therapy·Marilyn MacKay-Lyons
Jan 22, 2002·Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews·Mark L LatashGregor Schöner
Mar 5, 2002·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Ary L GoldbergerH Eugene Stanley
Oct 31, 2002·Nature Neuroscience·Emanuel Todorov, Michael I Jordan
Feb 4, 2003·Nature Neuroscience·Andrea d'AvellaEmilio Bizzi
Jun 5, 2003·Chaos·Jonathan B. Dingwell, Joseph P. Cusumano
Oct 17, 2003·Journal of Neurophysiology·Robert J van BeersDaniel M Wolpert
Nov 7, 2003·Journal of Neurophysiology·Jonathan B DingwellFerdinando A Mussa-Ivaldi
Jan 16, 2004·Nature·Konrad P Körding, Daniel M Wolpert
Apr 23, 2004·Journal of Neurophysiology·Leah R BentBradford J McFadyen
Jun 16, 2004·Gait & Posture·Tammy M Owings, Mark D Grabiner
Jun 23, 2004·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Stephen H Scott
Aug 28, 2004·Nature Neuroscience·Emanuel Todorov
Feb 19, 2005·Science·Steve CollinsMartijn Wisse
Sep 16, 2005·Nature·Leslie C OsborneWilliam Bialek
Dec 24, 2005·Physiological Reviews·Serge RossignolJean-Pierre Gossard
Jan 4, 2006·Journal of Biomechanics·Jonathan B Dingwell, Laura C Marin
Feb 28, 2006·Biological cybernetics·Joseph P Cusumano, Paola Cesari
Apr 18, 2006·Nature Neuroscience·Mehrdad Jazayeri, J Anthony Movshon
Jul 29, 2006·Journal of Mathematical Biology·Carla M A Pinto, Martin Golubitsky

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Nov 12, 2013·Journal of Biomechanics·Daniel M Russell, Joshua L Haworth
Dec 5, 2013·Physiological Reports·Christian MaurerBenno M Nigg
Sep 4, 2014·Experimental Brain Research·Jeffrey C CowleyDeanna H Gates
Dec 29, 2010·PLoS Computational Biology·Jie ZhangMichael Small
Jun 23, 2012·Journal of Neurophysiology·Rajiv Ranganathan, Chandramouli Krishnan
Oct 12, 2012·Journal of Neurophysiology·Jonathan B DingwellJoseph P Cusumano
Feb 21, 2013·Journal of Biological Engineering·Arthur T Johnson
Sep 21, 2010·Experimental Brain Research·David LoganJohn J Jeka
Jul 5, 2012·Journal of Biomechanical Engineering·Hung P Nguyen, Jonathan B Dingwell
Dec 15, 2015·Experimental Brain Research·Daniel M RussellCesar Martinez-Garza
Oct 16, 2012·Bio Systems·Oscar Vilarroya
Oct 4, 2012·Trends in Cognitive Sciences·Stephen H Scott
Nov 3, 2010·Clinical Biomechanics·Shane R WurdemanNicholas Stergiou
Aug 17, 2010·Journal of Biomechanics·Paulien E Roos, Jonathan B Dingwell
Jul 8, 2010·Gait & Posture·Jonathan B Dingwell, Joseph P Cusumano
Jan 5, 2016·Journal of Biomechanics·Nicole K Bohnsack-McLaganJonathan B Dingwell
Jun 20, 2012·IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering·A T JohnsonJ Vossoughi
Nov 12, 2013·Human Movement Science·Joseph P Cusumano, Jonathan B Dingwell
Feb 14, 2012·Journal of Biomechanics·Patricia M McAndrew YoungJonathan B Dingwell
Jan 23, 2013·Gait & Posture·Leslie M DeckerNicholas Stergiou
Mar 29, 2011·Journal of Biomechanics·Paulien E Roos, Jonathan B Dingwell
Jun 4, 2015·Journal of Biomechanics·Megan E Reissman, Yasin Y Dhaher
Aug 23, 2012·PloS One·Leslie M DeckerNicholas Stergiou
Apr 25, 2015·PloS One·Jonathan B Dingwell, Joseph P Cusumano
Aug 19, 2016·Experimental Brain Research·Dennis HamacherLutz Schega
Sep 20, 2016·PLoS Computational Biology·Joby JohnJoseph P Cusumano
Mar 22, 2013·Journal of the Royal Society, Interface·S M BruijnJ H van Dieën
Mar 14, 2017·Scientific Reports·Klaudia KozlowskaBruce J West
Jun 2, 2017·Gait & Posture·Mandy M SalinasJonathan B Dingwell
Nov 27, 2016·The Journal of Experimental Biology·Soran AminiaghdamReinhard Blickhan
Mar 5, 2019·PLoS Computational Biology·Joshua G A CashabackPaul L Gribble
Mar 7, 2019·PLoS Computational Biology·Jonathan B Dingwell, Joseph P Cusumano
Jun 28, 2016·Scientific Reports·Dobromir G DotovSimone Dalla Bella
Sep 8, 2012·Annals of Biomedical Engineering·Jeffrey P KaipustNicholas Stergiou
Feb 24, 2016·Annals of Biomedical Engineering·Philippe Terrier
Apr 11, 2014·Journal of Neurophysiology·David LoganJohn J Jeka

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Software Mentioned

MATLAB
MIP

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Cajal Bodies & Gems

Cajal bodies or coiled bodies are dense foci of coilin protein. Gemini of Cajal bodies, or gems, are microscopically similar to Cajal bodies. It is believed that Cajal bodies play important roles in RNA processing while gems assist the Cajal bodies. Find the latest research on Cajal bodies and gems here.