High proportions of bacteria and archaea across most biomes remain uncultured

The ISME Journal
Andrew D SteenJ Cameron Thrash

Abstract

A recent paper by Martiny argues that "high proportions" of bacteria in diverse Earth environments have been cultured. Here we reanalyze a portion of the data in that paper, and argue that the conclusion is based on several technical errors, most notably a calculation of sequence similarity that does not account for sequence gaps, and the reliance on 16S rRNA gene amplicons that are known to be biased towards cultured organisms. We further argue that the paper is also based on a conceptual error: namely, that sequence similarity cannot be used to infer "culturability" because one cannot infer physiology from 16S rRNA gene sequences. Combined with other recent, more reliable studies, the evidence supports the conclusion that most bacterial and archaeal taxa remain uncultured.

References

Oct 6, 1998·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·M F Polz, C M Cavanaugh
Nov 15, 2000·FEMS Microbiology Reviews·M SchloterA Hartmann
Nov 20, 2002·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Karsten ZenglerMartin Keller
Feb 11, 2005·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Konstantinos T Konstantinidis, James M Tiedje
May 1, 2007·Nucleic Acids Research·S SmitR Knight
May 30, 2008·Nature·Cara M SantelliKatrina J Edwards
Apr 13, 2011·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Chengwei LuoKonstantinos T Konstantinidis
Mar 1, 2012·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·S BuergerS S Epstein
Oct 13, 2012·Microbes and Environments·Indun Dewi PuspitaCindy H Nakatsu
Nov 30, 2012·Nucleic Acids Research·Christian QuastFrank Oliver Glöckner
Nov 30, 2013·Nucleic Acids Research·James R ColeJames M Tiedje
Aug 15, 2014·Nature Reviews. Microbiology·Pablo YarzaRamon Rosselló-Móra
Oct 5, 2014·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·Tomohiro TanakaYoichi Kamagata
Jun 18, 2015·Nature·Christopher T BrownJillian F Banfield
Oct 16, 2015·Nature Communications·Matthew A OberhardtEytan Ruppin
May 18, 2016·MBio·Patrick D SchlossJ Cameron Thrash
Aug 31, 2016·Nature Microbiology·Emiley A Eloe-FadroshNikos C Kyrpides
Aug 31, 2016·Nature Microbiology·Laura A HugJillian F Banfield
Oct 30, 2016·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·Grace PoldKristen M DeAngelis
Feb 12, 2017·Environmental Microbiology Reports·Alyse A Larkin, Adam C Martiny
Mar 14, 2018·Nature Protocols·Brittany BerdySlava S Epstein
Jul 22, 2018·Applied and Environmental Microbiology·Souichiro KatoYoichi Kamagata
Apr 7, 2019·The ISME Journal·Adam C Martiny

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Oct 11, 2019·Nature Biotechnology·William H Lewis, Thijs J G Ettema
Sep 26, 2019·The ISME Journal·Adam C Martiny
Apr 15, 2020·Current Protocols in Cytometry·Hazel Davey, Stéphane Guyot
Jul 7, 2020·Journal of Applied Microbiology·Fluvio ModolonRaquel S Peixoto
Aug 12, 2020·PloS One·Gian Maria Niccolò BenucciGregory Bonito
Aug 6, 2020·Ecological Applications : a Publication of the Ecological Society of America·Noël P D Juvigny-KhenafouChristoph D Matthaei
Aug 22, 2020·Science Advances·J A BradleyD E LaRowe
Feb 15, 2020·Nature Reviews. Microbiology·Roland HatzenpichlerZackary J Jay
Aug 16, 2019·Nature Reviews. Microbiology·Ursula Hofer
Jun 14, 2020·Nature Reviews. Genetics·Amy K CainTim van Opijnen
Aug 30, 2020·Communications Biology·Stephanie D JurburgAnna Heintz-Buschart
Sep 18, 2020·Microbiome·Zheng ZhangYuezhong Li
Jun 10, 2020·Nature Microbiology·Alison E MurrayAnna-Louise Reysenbach
Oct 6, 2020·Environmental Microbiology Reports·Karen G Lloyd
Oct 15, 2020·Scientific Data·Kira MoonJang-Cheon Cho
Jul 9, 2020·Bioinformatics·Connor Morgan-LangSteven J Hallam
Oct 20, 2020·Environmental Microbiology Reports·J Cameron Thrash
Jan 26, 2021·Frontiers in Microbiology·Esther Molina-MenorManuel Porcar
Jan 30, 2021·Nature Microbiology·Paul Carini
Nov 27, 2020·Frontiers in Genetics·Madangchanok ImchenVasco Azevedo
Feb 16, 2021·Frontiers in Microbiology·Angel Rain-FrancoSara Beier
Feb 25, 2021·The Journal of Microbiology·Kira Moon, Jang-Cheon Cho
Feb 27, 2021·Frontiers in Microbiology·Ilenne Del ValleLauren B Stadler
Oct 15, 2020·The ISME Journal·Yongjian ChenAlbert Barberán
Mar 11, 2021·International Journal of Medical Microbiology : IJMM·Thomas C A HitchThomas Clavel
Apr 26, 2021·Ecology Letters·Mark WestobySasha G Tetu
May 5, 2021·Molecular Ecology Resources·Stephanie D JurburgJonathan M Chase
May 14, 2021·PLoS Pathogens·Emily J StevensKayla C King

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Methods Mentioned

BETA
PCR

Software Mentioned

CD
UPARSE
HIT
mothur
SeqMatch
USEARCH
BLAST

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Archaeogenetics

Recent advances in genomic sequencing has led to the discovery of new strains of Archaea and shed light on their evolutionary history. Discover the latest research on Archaeogenetics here.