Abstract
Deep brain stimulation (DBS) can provide dramatic essential tremor (ET) relief, however no Class I evidence exists. Analysis methods: I) traditional cohort analysis; II) N-of-1 single patient randomised control trial and III) signal-to-noise (S/N) analysis. 20 DBS electrodes in ET patients were switched on and off for 3-min periods. Six pairs of on and off periods in each case, with the pair order determined randomly. Tremor severity was quantified with tremor evaluator and patient was blinded to stimulation. Patients also stated whether they perceived the stimulation to be on after each trial. I) Mean end-of-trial tremor severity 0.84 out of 10 on, 6.62 Off, t = - 13.218, p < 0.0005. II) N-of-1: 60% of cases had 12 correct perceptions (p = 0.001), 20% had 11 correct perceptions (p = 0.013). III) S/N: > 80% tremor reduction occurred in 99/114 'On' trials (87%), and 3/114 'Off' trials (3%). S/N ratio for 80% improvement with DBS versus spontaneous improvement was 487,757-to-1. DBS treatment effect on ET is too large for bias to be a plausible explanation. Formal N-of-1 trial design, and S/N ratio method for presenting results, allows this to be demonstrated convincingly where conventional randomised controlled trials are not pos...Continue Reading
References
Feb 16, 1991·Lancet·A L BenabidJ de Rougemont
Mar 29, 1986·Lancet·R S McLeodJ B Cullen
Apr 3, 1986·The New England Journal of Medicine·G GuyattS Pugsley
Jun 1, 1994·Annals of Neurology·W C KollerK Miner
Aug 1, 1993·Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry·P G BainC D Marsden
Nov 25, 1998·Movement Disorders : Official Journal of the Movement Disorder Society·M F Brin, W Koller
Oct 26, 1999·Neurology·R PahwaW C Koller
Feb 10, 2000·Pain·D CarrollT Z Aziz
Nov 23, 2006·Nature Clinical Practice. Neurology·Julián Benito-León, Elan D Louis
Feb 17, 2007·BMJ : British Medical Journal·Paul GlasziouPeter McCulloch
Sep 14, 2007·Expert Review of Medical Devices·Erlick A C PereiraTipu Z Aziz
Apr 23, 2009·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·Morten L Kringelbach, Tipu Z Aziz
Sep 29, 2009·Lancet·Jeffrey S BarkunJan Vandenbroucke
Sep 28, 2010·Lancet·Peter McCulloch, Frank Schuller
Jan 25, 2011·Lancet Neurology·Günther DeuschlRodger Elble
Feb 3, 2011·Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry·Puneet PlahaSteven Gill
Mar 26, 2011·Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry·Elan D LouisAmanda S Viner
Apr 12, 2011·Medical Care·Nicole B GablerRichard L Kravitz
Apr 14, 2011·Nature Reviews. Neurology·Félix Bermejo-Pareja
Oct 21, 2011·Neurology·T A ZesiewiczW J Weiner
Apr 1, 2004·Neuromodulation : Journal of the International Neuromodulation Society·Alexander L GreenTipu Z Aziz
Citations
Mar 24, 2016·Neuromodulation : Journal of the International Neuromodulation Society·Umer AkbarMichael S Okun
Aug 22, 2015·Movement Disorders : Official Journal of the Movement Disorder Society·Alfonso Fasano, Günther Deuschl
Sep 19, 2015·Parkinsonism & Related Disorders·Marina Picillo, Alfonso Fasano
Jul 1, 2015·Journal of Clinical Neuroscience : Official Journal of the Neurosurgical Society of Australasia·Sandra G J BoccardTipu Z Aziz
Feb 25, 2018·Expert Review of Neurotherapeutics·Rodger J ElbleJeffrey W Cozzens
Mar 8, 2018·Journal of Neurology·Carlo Alberto ArtusiAristide Merola
Jun 2, 2020·British Journal of Neurosurgery·Hansen DengDoris D Wang
Mar 12, 2016·Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin
Jul 12, 2020·Acta neurochirurgica·Helen C U OtaAngelos Kolias