Abstract
Functional MRI shows promise as a candidate prognostication method in acutely comatose patients following severe brain injury. However, further research is needed before this technique becomes appropriate for clinical practice. Drawing on a clinical case, we investigate the process of obtaining informed consent for this kind of research and identify four ethical issues. After describing each issue, we propose potential solutions which would make a patient's participation in research compatible with her rights and interests. First, we defend the need for traditional proxy consent against two alternative approaches. Second, we examine the impact of the intensive care unit environment on the informed consent process. Third, we discuss the therapeutic misconception and its potential influence on informed consent. Finally, we deal with issues of timing in recruiting participants and related factors which may affect the risks of participation.
References
Apr 8, 2003·Social Philosophy & Policy·Rebecca Dresser
Oct 7, 2004·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·James Flory, Ezekiel Emanuel
Feb 3, 2005·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Eric RacineJudy Illes
Jul 26, 2006·Neurology·E F M WijdicksUNKNOWN Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology
Jul 20, 2007·Neurology·A O RossettiM Oddo
Sep 7, 2007·Cognition·David P McCabe, Alan D Castel
Nov 17, 2007·Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience·Deena Skolnick WeisbergJeremy R Gray
Feb 21, 2008·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Adrian M Owen, Martin R Coleman
Feb 25, 2009·Neurology·Andrea O RossettiPeter W Kaplan
Mar 25, 2009·Experimental Neurology·Teneille E GoftonSeyed M Mirsattari
Apr 10, 2010·American Journal of Critical Care : an Official Publication, American Association of Critical-Care Nurses·Karen E A BurnsDeborah J Cook
May 18, 2010·Critical Care : the Official Journal of the Critical Care Forum·Benoît FanaraGilles Capellier
Sep 13, 2011·Annals of Intensive Care·Henry Silverman
Jan 6, 2012·Neurology·L NortonS M Mirsattari
Jun 9, 2012·Chest·Ellen IversonBradley D Freeman
Jul 25, 2012·Intensive Care Medicine·Kali A BarrettDamon C Scales
Nov 22, 2012·Clinical Trials : Journal of the Society for Clinical Trials·Mary E LarkinSteven J Russell
Mar 26, 2013·American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine·Karen E A BurnsUNKNOWN Canadian Critical Care Trials Group
Jul 25, 2013·BMC Medical Ethics·Adam NishimuraJennifer B McCormick
Jan 28, 2014·Neurocritical Care·Matthew A KoenigLinda Chang
Sep 17, 2015·Brain : a Journal of Neurology·Charles WeijerAdrian M Owen
Sep 1, 2017·Bioethics·Pat McConville
Citations
May 16, 2019·Journal of Medical Ethics·John McMillan
Oct 17, 2019·Neuroscience of Consciousness·Andrew PetersonCharles Weijer
Oct 26, 2020·Lancet Neurology·Erwin J O KompanjeWilco C Peul
Jul 16, 2021·Journal of Medical Ethics·Amanda van BeinumJennifer Chandler