Inherent problems with randomized clinical trials with observational/no treatment arms

Journal of Vascular Surgery
Clifford J BuckleyShirley D Buckley

Abstract

Randomized clinical trials (RCTs) offering an observation/no treatment (OBS/NoRx) arm as control and which are focused on the management of a condition with potentially life-threatening consequences, however small the risk, often experience a significant rate of crossover to treatment by those randomized to the OBS/NoRx arm. Results of these trials when analyzed on intent-to-treat basis often fail to resolve the issue at which they were directed. The authors have observed this in trials of abdominal aortic aneurysms with this design and use these to exemplify the dilemmas RCTs of such design create, with crossovers ranging from 27% to over 60% (EVAR II, UKSAT, ADAM, PIVOTAL). Results of these trials are frequently used as level I medical evidence and their potential impact on clinical decision making and reimbursement can be quite significant and long-lasting. Recommendations regarding trial end points and suggestions to mitigate the high crossover effect are offered. It may be that some clinical conditions dealing with potentially life-threatening problems should not be studied in randomized prospective clinical trials containing an OBS/NoRx arm.

References

Oct 27, 1998·European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery : the Official Journal of the European Society for Vascular Surgery·J M PerkinsP J Morris
Jan 12, 1999·Journal of Vascular Surgery·J L Cronenwett, K W Johnston
Aug 25, 2000·Journal of Vascular Surgery·R J ValentineG P Clagett
May 10, 2002·The New England Journal of Medicine·Frank A LederleUNKNOWN Aneurysm Detection and Management Veterans Affairs Cooperative Study Group
May 10, 2002·The New England Journal of Medicine·UNKNOWN United Kingdom Small Aneurysm Trial ParticipantsS G Thompson
Jun 28, 2005·Lancet·Jack L Cronenwett
Apr 9, 2008·Circulation·B Timothy BaxterRonald L Dalman

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Nov 14, 2013·Journal of Nuclear Medicine : Official Publication, Society of Nuclear Medicine·Bruce E HillnerBarry A Siegel
Jan 31, 2012·Current Cardiology Reports·April A GrantBruce H Gray
Feb 13, 2016·Health Technology Assessment : HTA·Robert C SteinUNKNOWN OPTIMA Trial Management Group
Dec 14, 2011·Seminars in Vascular Surgery·Clifford J BuckleyShirley D Buckley
Nov 13, 2014·European Journal of Clinical Investigation·Mohammad GolfamJulian Little
Sep 22, 2018·Gefässchirurgie : Zeitschrift für vaskuläre und endovaskuläre Chirurgie : Organ der Deutschen und der Österreichischen Gesellschaft für Gefässchirurgie unter Mitarbeit der Schweizerischen Gesellschaft für Gefässchirurgie·M D ShahR C Darling Iii
Feb 25, 2020·Clinical Oncology : a Journal of the Royal College of Radiologists·C ConefreyUNKNOWN OPTIMA Prelim Study Group

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Aneurysm

Aneurysms are outward distensions or bulges that occurs in a weakened wall of blood vessels. Discover the latest research on aneurysms here.

Aortic Aneurysm

An aortic aneurysm is the weakening and bulging of the blood vessel wall in the aorta. This causes dilatation of the aorta, which is usually asymptomatic but carries the risk of rupture and hemorrhage. Find the latest research on aortic aneurysms here.

Related Papers

Seminars in Vascular Surgery
Clifford J BuckleyShirley D Buckley
European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery : the Official Journal of the European Society for Vascular Surgery
Christopher K ZarinsR A White
Journal of Endovascular Therapy : an Official Journal of the International Society of Endovascular Specialists
Kenneth Ouriel
© 2021 Meta ULC. All rights reserved