Interpreting low template DNA profiles

Forensic Science International. Genetics
D J Balding, John S Buckleton

Abstract

We discuss the interpretation of DNA profiles obtained from low template DNA samples. The most important challenge to interpretation in this setting arises when either or both of "drop-out" and "drop-in" create discordances between the crime scene DNA profile and the DNA profile expected under the prosecution allegation. Stutter and unbalanced peak heights are also problematic, in addition to the effects of masking from the profile of a known contributor. We outline a framework for assessing such evidence, based on likelihood ratios that involve drop-out and drop-in probabilities, and apply it to two casework examples. Our framework extends previous work, including new approaches to modelling homozygote drop-out and uncertainty in allele calls for stutter, masking and near-threshold peaks. We show that some current approaches to interpretation, such as ignoring a discrepant locus or reporting a "Random Man Not Excluded" (RMNE) probability, can be systematically unfair to defendants, sometimes extremely so. We also show that the LR can depend strongly on the assumed value for the drop-out probability, and there is typically no approximation that is useful for all values. We illustrate that ignoring the possibility of drop-in is ...Continue Reading

References

Jan 1, 1997·International Journal of Legal Medicine·I W EvettC Kimpton
May 16, 2002·Science & Justice : Journal of the Forensic Science Society·J M CurranB S Weir
Sep 22, 2005·Forensic Science International : Synergy·John Buckleton, Christopher Triggs
Oct 18, 2005·Forensic Science International : Synergy·John Buckleton, Chris Triggs
Jun 6, 2006·Forensic Science International : Synergy·P GillUNKNOWN DNA commission of the International Society of Forensic Genetics
Jun 9, 2006·Forensic Science International : Synergy·Peter GillJames Curran
Mar 1, 2007·Forensic Science International. Genetics·John S BuckletonPeter Gill
Dec 17, 2008·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Niels MorlingPeter M Schneider
Dec 17, 2008·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peter GillUNKNOWN Technical UK DNA working group
Dec 17, 2008·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peter GillJim Lambert
Feb 14, 2009·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peter GillJames Curran
Feb 14, 2009·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peta StringerSallyAnn Harbison
Aug 4, 2009·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Torben TvedebrinkNiels Morling

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Jul 17, 2012·International Journal of Legal Medicine·David H WarshauerBruce Budowle
Dec 10, 2013·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Vince L Pascali, Sara Merigioli
Jul 3, 2013·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·David J Balding
Nov 11, 2010·BMC Research Notes·Johannes HedmanAnders Nordgaard
Dec 3, 2010·Investigative Genetics·Roland Ah van OorschotR John Mitchell
Jan 16, 2013·Investigative Genetics·Jolanta Draus-BariniManfred Kayser
Dec 19, 2009·PloS One·Mark W Perlin, Alexander Sinelnikov
Mar 10, 2011·Nanomedicine·Emiliano GiardinaGiuseppe Novelli
Oct 27, 2012·Croatian Medical Journal·Melanie HarderNicole von Wurmb-Schwark
Oct 8, 2013·International Journal of Legal Medicine·Jianye Ge, Bruce Budowle
Feb 7, 2016·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Clare D MarsdenKirk E Lohmueller
Dec 31, 2015·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Carlos M VulloThomas Parsons
Dec 27, 2015·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Duncan TaylorJohn Buckleton
Feb 26, 2016·Forensic Science International. Genetics·K Slooten
Mar 26, 2013·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Claus BørstingNiels Morling
Oct 16, 2012·Best Practice & Research. Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology·Mary Newton
Sep 18, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·H HanedP Gill
Sep 25, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Adele A MitchellTheresa Caragine
Sep 6, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Vince L Pascali, Sara Merigioli
Jul 15, 2015·International Journal of Legal Medicine·Klaas-Jan Slooten, Thore Egeland
Jul 17, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Christine A RakayCatherine M Grgicak
Aug 28, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Hannah KellyJohn Buckleton
Jul 31, 2012·Science & Justice : Journal of the Forensic Science Society·Andrew J HopwoodGillian Tully
Jun 29, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Céline M PfeiferPeter Wiegand
May 23, 2012·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Corina C G BenschopTitia Sijen
Aug 16, 2011·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Jo-Anne BrightJohn Buckleton
Apr 2, 2011·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Natalie E C WeilerTitia Sijen
Dec 17, 2010·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peter M SchneiderAngel Carracedo
Oct 19, 2010·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Simon CowenKerry Way
Oct 19, 2010·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Jo-Anne BrightJohn Buckleton
May 12, 2010·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Peter Gill, John Buckleton
Mar 8, 2016·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Harish SwaminathanDesmond S Lun
Aug 27, 2014·Journal of Theoretical Biology·Duncan TaylorJohn Buckleton
Oct 23, 2012·Journal of Forensic Sciences·Kirk E Lohmueller, Norah Rudin
May 22, 2010·Journal of Forensic Sciences·James M Curran, John Buckleton
Aug 11, 2011·Journal of Forensic Sciences·Mark W PerlinBarry W Duceman
Mar 16, 2016·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Duncan TaylorLauren Rask-Nielsen
Sep 28, 2014·Forensic Science International. Genetics·Duncan TaylorJohn Buckleton

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Absence Epilepsy

Absence epilepsy is a common seizure disorder in children which can produce chronic psychosocial sequelae. Discover the latest research on absence epilepsies here.

Related Papers

Forensic Science International : Synergy
John S Buckleton, Christopher Triggs
Forensic Science International : Synergy
Peter GillJames M Curran
Forensic Science International. Genetics
Torben TvedebrinkNiels Morling
© 2022 Meta ULC. All rights reserved