Probabilistic population codes for Bayesian decision making

Neuron
Jeffrey M BeckAlexandre Pouget

Abstract

When making a decision, one must first accumulate evidence, often over time, and then select the appropriate action. Here, we present a neural model of decision making that can perform both evidence accumulation and action selection optimally. More specifically, we show that, given a Poisson-like distribution of spike counts, biological neural networks can accumulate evidence without loss of information through linear integration of neural activity and can select the most likely action through attractor dynamics. This holds for arbitrary correlations, any tuning curves, continuous and discrete variables, and sensory evidence whose reliability varies over time. Our model predicts that the neurons in the lateral intraparietal cortex involved in evidence accumulation encode, on every trial, a probability distribution which predicts the animal's performance. We present experimental evidence consistent with this prediction and discuss other predictions applicable to more general settings.

References

Jan 1, 1982·Experimental Brain Research·G Sclar, R D Freeman
Nov 1, 1993·Visual Neuroscience·K H BrittenJ Anthony Movshon
Jan 15, 2000·Neural Computation·H E Plesser, W Gerstner
Feb 13, 2001·Trends in Cognitive Sciences·Joshua I Gold, Michael N Shadlen
Aug 8, 2001·Psychological Review·M Usher, J L McClelland
Jul 15, 2003·Nature Neuroscience·Jochen DitterichMichael N Shadlen
Sep 27, 2003·Neural Computation·M J BarberC H Anderson
Oct 25, 2003·Cerebral Cortex·Mark E MazurekMichael N Shadlen
Mar 24, 2004·Trends in Neurosciences·Philip L Smith, Roger Ratcliff
Jun 19, 2004·Science·Leo P SugrueWilliam T Newsome
Jul 10, 2004·Journal of Physiology, Paris·Peter E LathamAlexandre Pouget
Dec 17, 2004·Network : Computation in Neural Systems·Liam Paninski
Feb 19, 2005·Science·Christian K MachensCarlos D Brody
Apr 9, 2005·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Adam Kohn, Matthew A Smith
Nov 11, 2005·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Alexander C Huk, Michael N Shadlen
Jan 27, 2006·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Kong-Fatt Wong, Xiao-Jing Wang
Oct 24, 2006·Nature Neuroscience·Wei Ji MaAlexandre Pouget
Jan 9, 2007·Neural Computation·Rafal Bogacz, Kevin N Gurney
Jun 30, 2007·Annual Review of Neuroscience·Joshua I Gold, Michael N Shadlen
Mar 21, 2008·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Byounghoon Kim, Michele A Basso
Mar 21, 2008·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Roozbeh KianiMichael N Shadlen
May 20, 2008·Nature Neuroscience·Anne K ChurchlandMichael N Shadlen
Dec 27, 2008·Neuron·Moran Furman, Xiao-Jing Wang

Citations

Jan 22, 2013·Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology·Sarah L Karalunas, Cynthia Huang-Pollock
Sep 5, 2009·Cognitive Neurodynamics·Jerome Feldman
Jan 31, 2014·Visual Neuroscience·J Anthony Movshon
Aug 21, 2009·Nature·Arbora ResulajMichael N Shadlen
Nov 17, 2009·Nature Neuroscience·Marlene R Cohen, John H R Maunsell
Dec 17, 2009·Nature Neuroscience·Alireza Soltani, Xiao-Jing Wang
Jan 26, 2010·Nature Neuroscience·Terrence R StanfordEmilio Salinas
Jan 11, 2011·Nature Neuroscience·Arnulf B A GrafJ Anthony Movshon
Apr 5, 2011·Nature Neuroscience·Vikranth R BejjankiAlexandre Pouget
May 10, 2011·Nature Neuroscience·Wei Ji MaAlexandre Pouget
Jun 29, 2011·Nature Neuroscience·Marlene R Cohen, Adam Kohn
Aug 21, 2013·Nature Neuroscience·Alexandre PougetPeter E Latham
Feb 21, 2009·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Rodrigo Quian Quiroga, Stefano Panzeri
Jun 6, 2009·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Larissa Albantakis, Gustavo Deco
Sep 15, 2010·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Marko NardiniDenis Mareschal
Feb 9, 2012·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Ronald van den BergWei Ji Ma
Dec 28, 2012·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Yarden Cohen, Elad Schneidman
Nov 1, 2012·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Federico CarnevaleNéstor Parga
Apr 12, 2012·Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences·Nick Yeung, Christopher Summerfield
Jul 7, 2009·Annual Review of Psychology·Richard A AndersenGrant H Mulliken
Jul 16, 2010·Journal of Neurophysiology·Miranda Scolari, John T Serences
Dec 25, 2009·Journal of Neurophysiology·Andrew S KayserMark D'Esposito
Nov 25, 2011·Journal of Neurophysiology·Peter W Jones, Fabrizio Gabbiani
Apr 23, 2010·Journal of Neurophysiology·John T Serences, Sameer Saproo
Oct 22, 2009·Neural Computation·Tyler McMillen, Sam Behseta
Dec 24, 2009·Neural Computation·Jiaxiang Zhang, Rafal Bogacz
Feb 3, 2012·Neural Computation·Kentaro KatahiraMasato Okada
Mar 21, 2012·Neural Computation·Stuart YarrowPeggy Seriès
Aug 28, 2012·Neural Computation·Nathan F Lepora, Kevin N Gurney
Nov 15, 2012·Neural Computation·Nicholas Cain, Eric Shea-Brown
Jun 4, 2013·Neural Computation·Carina CurtoJudy L Walker
May 15, 2013·Neural Computation·Andreas Steimer, Rodney Douglas
Dec 2, 2011·PLoS Biology·Floris P de LangeStanislas Dehaene
Mar 8, 2011·PLoS Computational Biology·Martin Boerlin, Sophie Deneve
Apr 13, 2011·PLoS Computational Biology·Edward J A TurnhamDaniel M Wolpert
Feb 24, 2012·PLoS Computational Biology·Johannes RüterMichael H Herzog
Apr 20, 2014·PLoS Computational Biology·Andrea InsabatoRanulfo Romo
Jul 14, 2011·PloS One·Thomas H WeisswangeJochen Triesch
Aug 24, 2012·PloS One·Larissa AlbantakisGustavo Deco
May 13, 2014·PloS One·Jan DrugowitschAlexandre Pouget
Jun 8, 2012·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Tiffany HoJohn T Serences
Aug 3, 2012·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Philipp BerensAndreas S Tolias
Jun 10, 2011·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Swetha ShankarEmilio Salinas
Feb 12, 2010·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Byounghoon Kim, Michele A Basso
Oct 18, 2013·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Roozbeh KianiMichael N Shadlen
Feb 9, 2013·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Miriam L R MeisterAlexander C Huk
Mar 17, 2012·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Jan DrugowitschAlexandre Pouget
Mar 9, 2012·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Braden A PurcellThomas J Palmeri
Apr 29, 2011·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Timothy D HanksMichael N Shadlen
Mar 25, 2011·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Douglas D GarrettCheryl L Grady
Jul 21, 2012·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Vinod RaoLawrence H Snyder
Dec 14, 2011·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·He Cui, Richard A Andersen
Apr 1, 2011·The Journal of Neuroscience : the Official Journal of the Society for Neuroscience·Kris S Chaisanguanthum, Stephen G Lisberger
Apr 2, 2009·Chaos·Marzena CiszakF Tito Arecchi
Sep 7, 2013·Brain Imaging and Behavior·Cheryl L Grady, Douglas D Garrett
Feb 20, 2014·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Bram ZandbeltJeffrey D Schall
Jun 16, 2014·ELife·Jan DrugowitschAlexandre Pouget
Sep 1, 2014·Nature Neuroscience·Il Memming ParkJonathan W Pillow
Jul 18, 2014·Annual Review of Neuroscience·Wei Ji Ma, Mehrdad Jazayeri
Jun 22, 2012·Annual Review of Neuroscience·Daphne BavelierPaul Schrater
Apr 3, 2012·Annual Review of Neuroscience·Daeyeol LeeMin Whan Jung
Nov 26, 2013·Journal of Computational Neuroscience·Sam CarrollZachary P Kilpatrick
Jan 31, 2012·Attention, Perception & Psychophysics·Leendert van MaanenEric-Jan Wagenmakers
Dec 29, 2015·NeuroImage·Bernhard SpitzerChristopher Summerfield
Dec 15, 2015·ELife·Nicholas E MyersMark G Stokes
Jan 23, 2016·Attention, Perception & Psychophysics·Brian ManiscalcoHakwan Lau
Mar 6, 2013·Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews·Douglas D GarrettCheryl L Grady
Feb 26, 2016·Nature Neuroscience·Brent DoironKrešimir Josić
Feb 26, 2016·Nature Neuroscience·Alexandre PougetAdam Kepecs
Nov 22, 2011·Journal of Neuroscience Methods·Ki Yong KwonKarim Oweiss
Jul 12, 2011·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Timm Lochmann, Sophie Deneve
Jun 11, 2011·Neural Networks : the Official Journal of the International Neural Network Society·Dominic Standage, Martin Paré
Mar 25, 2011·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Aaron M Bornstein, Nathaniel D Daw
Mar 8, 2011·Neural Networks : the Official Journal of the International Neural Network Society·Tyler McMillenSam Behseta
Feb 12, 2011·Neural Networks : the Official Journal of the International Neural Network Society·Zhihua Wu, Aike Guo
Feb 9, 2011·World Neurosurgery·Michael J Lang, Garnette R Sutherland
Jun 15, 2010·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Nicole C Rust, Alan A Stocker
Apr 20, 2010·Trends in Cognitive Sciences·Jacqueline Gottlieb, Puiu Balan
Mar 27, 2010·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Antonio Rangel, Todd Hare
Feb 16, 2010·Trends in Cognitive Sciences·József FiserMáté Lengyel
Oct 13, 2009·Trends in Neurosciences·Rafal BogaczSander Nieuwenhuis
Mar 5, 2016·Scientific Reports·Chihiro I TajimaHideyuki Suzuki
Dec 19, 2014·Neuron·Roozbeh KianiMichael N Shadlen
Aug 6, 2008·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Wei Ji MaAlexandre Pouget
Jul 31, 2012·Neurosurgery·Ayguel MertStefan Wolfsberger
Oct 27, 2015·Nature Neuroscience·Ruben S van BergenJanneke F M Jehee
Oct 9, 2015·Neuron·Florent MeynielZachary F Mainen
Jun 9, 2014·Neuron·John M PearsonMichael L Platt
Apr 14, 2011·Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences·Iris Vilares, Konrad P Kording
Nov 1, 2010·Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews. Cognitive Science·Nick ChaterEvan Heit
Jun 8, 2011·The European Journal of Neuroscience·Jeffrey D SchallThomas J Palmeri
Jun 8, 2011·The European Journal of Neuroscience·Kelly ShenMartin Paré
Dec 26, 2009·Vision Research·Dario L Ringach
Feb 18, 2015·Neural Networks : the Official Journal of the International Neural Network Society·Johannes BauerStefan Wermter
Aug 22, 2014·Neuron·Victor de Lafuente, Ranulfo Romo
Apr 16, 2013·BioMed Research International·Jiajia ChenBairong Shen
Apr 5, 2012·Progress in Neurobiology·Ranulfo Romo, Victor de Lafuente
Aug 14, 2012·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Jan Drugowitsch, Alexandre Pouget
Jun 19, 2012·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Stanislas Dehaene, Mariano Sigman
Oct 3, 2012·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Xiao-Jing Wang
Nov 6, 2012·Progress in Neurobiology·Adrien WohrerChristian K Machens
Apr 9, 2014·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Robert L SeilheimerDora E Angelaki
Jun 22, 2011·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Gergo Orbán, Daniel M Wolpert
May 6, 2016·Neuron·Ralf M HaefnerJózsef Fiser
May 2, 2015·Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews·Piercesare GrimaldiMichele A Basso
May 15, 2015·Consciousness and Cognition·M T ShermanR Kanai
Apr 20, 2016·Cognition·Peter D Kvam, Timothy J Pleskac
Feb 23, 2011·Neuron·Anne K ChurchlandMichael N Shadlen
Mar 25, 2014·Neuron·Samuel CheadleChristopher Summerfield
Nov 5, 2013·Neuron·Michael N Shadlen, Roozbeh Kiani
Mar 13, 2015·Attention, Perception & Psychophysics·Benjamin T Vincent
Jan 7, 2015·Medical Hypotheses·Philipp SchwartenbeckKarl Friston
Sep 14, 2010·Current Biology : CB·C Shawn GreenDaphne Bavelier
May 12, 2009·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Zachary F Mainen, Adam Kepecs
May 18, 2012·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Nicholas Cain, Eric Shea-Brown
Jul 10, 2012·Current Biology : CB·Thomas U Otto, Pascal Mamassian
May 21, 2011·Current Biology : CB·L Caitlin ElmoreAnthony A Wright
May 5, 2012·Current Opinion in Neurobiology·Anne K Churchland, Jochen Ditterich
Sep 18, 2012·Trends in Cognitive Sciences·Wei Ji Ma
Feb 14, 2012·Progress in Neurobiology·Gustavo DecoRanulfo Romo
Dec 27, 2008·Neuron·Moran Furman, Xiao-Jing Wang
Aug 31, 2011·Brain Research·Edmund T Rolls, Tristan J Webb
Sep 17, 2011·Brain Research·Laurent Bonnasse-Gahot, Jean-Pierre Nadal
Jan 7, 2015·Journal of Computational Neuroscience·Dylan RichBrian J Fischer
Nov 18, 2014·Frontiers in Neuroscience·Gerald E Loeb, Jeremy A Fishel
May 9, 2014·Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience·Christopher D FiorilloSu Z Hong
Jan 8, 2015·Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience·Gundula MeckenhäuserMartin P Nawrot
Jun 27, 2014·Frontiers in Neuroscience·Richard P Heitz
May 2, 2014·Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience·Pietro Perona
Aug 13, 2015·PLoS Computational Biology·Sebastian BitzerStefan J Kiebel
May 26, 2016·Brain and Cognition·Marte OttenYair Pinto
Jun 28, 2016·Neural Computation·Yanping Huang, Rajesh P N Rao
Aug 19, 2016·Nature Communications·Satohiro TajimaAlexandre Pouget
Sep 20, 2016·Nature Neuroscience·Akihiro FunamizuKenji Doya
Dec 28, 2016·PLoS Computational Biology·Laurence Aitchison, Máté Lengyel
Dec 29, 2016·PLoS Computational Biology·Florent MeynielStanislas Dehaene
Oct 16, 2015·PLoS Computational Biology·Ian KrajbichErnst Fehr
Feb 26, 2016·Scientific Reports·Luciano PazMariano Sigman
Mar 24, 2017·Neural Computation·Adrian E RadilloZachary P Kilpatrick
Jun 9, 2017·Neuron·Xaq Pitkow, Dora E Angelaki
Jun 29, 2014·Psychological Science·Vy A VoJessica F Cantlon
Jul 14, 2017·PloS One·Chandan Singh, William B Levy
Apr 4, 2018·PLoS Computational Biology·Javier A CaballeroKevin N Gurney
Oct 25, 2017·Neural Computation·Mohammadjavad FarajiWulfram Gerstner
Apr 14, 2018·Neural Computation·Matias CalderiniJean-Philippe Thivierge
Oct 13, 2018·Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences·Nathan J WispinskiCraig S Chapman
Aug 2, 2018·Journal of Neurophysiology·Bryan M Krause, Geoffrey M Ghose
Nov 20, 2018·Journal of Vision·Claire ChambersKonrad P Kording
Feb 24, 2010·Nature Neuroscience·Jan Drugowitsch, Alexandre Pouget
Apr 17, 2019·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Andreas MayerThierry Mora
Apr 23, 2019·Journal of Vision·Jason SamahaBradley R Postle
May 21, 2013·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Christopher R FetschDora E Angelaki
May 5, 2018·Nature Communications·Joshua I GlaserKonrad P Kording
May 20, 2018·Scientific Reports·Zachary P Kilpatrick
Aug 15, 2014·Journal of Neurophysiology·Brandon AubiePaul A Faure
Apr 8, 2015·PLoS Computational Biology·Nathan F Lepora, Giovanni Pezzulo
Jul 28, 2015·Review of Philosophy and Psychology·Gerd Gigerenzer
Feb 29, 2020·Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience·Andrea E Martin
Nov 17, 2019·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Jan DrugowitschAlexandre Pouget
Dec 13, 2019·Cerebral Cortex·Shaun L ClohertyJude F Mitchell
May 12, 2020·Cerebral Cortex·Vishal BharmauriaJohn Douglas Crawford
Jun 15, 2017·Scientific Reports·Klaudia GrechutaPaul F M J Verschure
Nov 14, 2017·Nature Human Behaviour·Megan A K PetersHakwan Lau
Apr 20, 2018·Nature Communications·Alice MizrahiDamien Querlioz
Aug 30, 2018·Nature Communications·Gouki OkazawaRoozbeh Kiani
Nov 13, 2018·Frontiers in Neural Circuits·Tristan A ChaplinLeo L Lui
May 28, 2019·Computational Brain & Behavior·Marc W HowardZoran Tiganj
May 10, 2019·Frontiers in Neural Circuits·Leonardo L GolloMichael Breakspear
Dec 5, 2019·Scientific Reports·Jakob JordanTom Tetzlaff
Aug 7, 2013·Journal of Neural Engineering·L ToninJ del R Millán
Jun 10, 2017·Neural Computation·Josue OrellanaRobert E Kass
Sep 19, 2018·Nature Neuroscience·Timothy R DarlingtonStephen G Lisberger
Aug 10, 2018·Nature Reviews. Neuroscience·Jason P GallivanJ Randall Flanagan
May 28, 2019·Nature Communications·Nadim A A AtiyaKongFatt Wong-Lin
Jul 9, 2020·Physical Review Letters·Tianqi Hou, Haiping Huang
Jun 4, 2020·Nature Communications·André G MendonçaZachary F Mainen
May 8, 2015·Journal of Neurophysiology·Ziqiang Wei, Xiao-Jing Wang
Nov 23, 2017·Neuroradiology·Danielle C FarrarRonald J Killiany
Apr 13, 2018·Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience·Pragathi P BalasubramaniBenjamin Y Hayden
Jul 5, 2019·Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology·Torben OttAdam Kepecs
Sep 3, 2010·Journal of Neurophysiology·Edmund T RollsGustavo Deco
Feb 23, 2017·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Hildward VandormaelChristopher Summerfield
Aug 1, 2017·Nature Neuroscience·Jacob L YatesAlexander C Huk
May 16, 2020·Frontiers in Neuroscience·Ying FangFeng Chen
Apr 2, 2020·Frontiers in Computational Neuroscience·Michael J Berry, Gašper Tkačik
Aug 2, 2020·Nature Communications·Jiwon Yeon, Dobromir Rahnev
May 1, 2009·Journal of Neurophysiology·Kenji Morita
Dec 25, 2019·Nature Neuroscience·Edgar Y WalkerAndreas S Tolias
Dec 6, 2019·Frontiers in Neuroscience·Carly A Shevinsky, Pamela Reinagel
May 21, 2019·Annual Review of Control, Robotics, and Autonomous Systems·Daniel McNamee, Daniel M Wolpert
May 23, 2018·Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America·Dan Bang, Stephen M Fleming
Oct 7, 2020·Nature Neuroscience·Mikio C AoiJonathan W Pillow
Dec 4, 2020·Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews·Maxwell J D RamsteadKarl Friston
Dec 16, 2020·ELife·Ulrik BeierholmUta Noppeney
Dec 29, 2020·The European Journal of Neuroscience·Orly HalperinAdam Zaidel
Feb 18, 2021·Neuron·Leonhard WaschkeDouglas D Garrett
Jul 20, 2019·Neuron·Hansem SohnMehrdad Jazayeri
Dec 6, 2016·Journal of Memory and Language·Chelsea Voskuilen, Roger Ratcliff
Feb 19, 2021·Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience·Ronald H Stevens, Trysha L Galloway
Dec 29, 2020·Journal of Neurophysiology·Jonathan D CoutinhoGunnar Blohm
Mar 23, 2021·Child Neuropsychology : a Journal on Normal and Abnormal Development in Childhood and Adolescence·Jason S Feldman, Cynthia Huang-Pollock
Apr 10, 2021·NeuroImage·Dazhi Yin, Marcus Kaiser
May 8, 2021·Nature Neuroscience·James M ShineMichael Breakspear
May 24, 2021·Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences·Ádám KoblingerMáté Lengyel
Jun 8, 2021·Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence·Sascha FrölichStefan J Kiebel

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Brain developing: Influences & Outcomes

This feed focuses on influences that affect the developing brain including genetics, fetal development, prenatal care, and gene-environment interactions. Here is the latest research in this field.