Abstract
This commentary re-emphasizes the aim of our recent review (David et al., 2018) and addresses some of the points raised in the adjacent commentary by M. Weiner and J. McKim, Food Funct., 2019, 10, DOI: 10.1039/C8FO01282B. In agreement with the commentary, the discussed review highlights the need to adequately understand the complex physicochemistry of the food additive carrageenan (CGN) and its fate in the alimentary canal. In fact, there is a realm of scientific findings that justify the continuation of an open discussion of CGN safety. This response emphasizes that there is sparse information on [i] the physicochemical properties of commercial CGN, [ii] human levels of exposure to CGN from foods, [iii] the role of CGN in gut microbiome dysbiosis and inflammation, and [iv] the effects of CGN on susceptible populations. As long as the determinants of the increased prevalence of chronic and autoimmune diseases are not identified, we must continue to explore the possible beneficial or deleterious effects that may arise from extrinsic factors, including food additives, and do so in meticulous independent studies.
References
Nov 1, 1976·Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology·M Engster, R Abraham
Jul 1, 1967·The Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology·W Anderson, J E Harthill
May 25, 1968·Nature·A J Baillie, W Anderson
Sep 13, 2001·Food Additives and Contaminants·Y UnoT Maitani
Mar 14, 2002·Toxicologic Pathology·Cynthia ShackelfordRonald Herbert
Jan 10, 2004·Toxicologic Pathology·James W CrissmanDaryl C Thake
Dec 29, 2004·Biophysical Chemistry·Gema MarceloM Pilar Tarazona
Oct 13, 2006·Food and Chemical Toxicology : an International Journal Published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association·Myra L WeinerSamuel M Cohen
Dec 13, 2006·Toxicologic Pathology·Daniel MortonPaul W Snyder
Oct 16, 2013·Molecular Medicine Reports·Hai-Yue JiangXiao-Jun Yan
Jan 17, 2015·Food and Chemical Toxicology : an International Journal Published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association·M L WeinerB Mahadevan
Feb 3, 2015·Food and Chemical Toxicology : an International Journal Published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association·James M McKimWilliam R Blakemore
Feb 14, 2015·Autoimmunity Reviews·Aaron Lerner, Torsten Matthias
Apr 20, 2016·Frontiers in Microbiology·Peris M MunyakaEhsan Khafipour
Oct 9, 2016·Molecular Nutrition & Food Research·Lulu FahoumUri Lesmes
Apr 28, 2017·Nutrition and Healthy Aging·Sumit BhattacharyyaJoanne K Tobacman
May 17, 2017·Frontiers in Pediatrics·John Vincent MartinoLeah E Cahill
Feb 23, 2018·Food & Function·Shlomit DavidUri Lesmes
Mar 14, 2018·Toxicologic Pathology·Kenneth A SchaferSabine Francke
Jun 15, 2018·Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition·James M McKimMyra L Weiner
Apr 26, 2018·EFSA Journal·UNKNOWN EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added to Food (ANS)Birgit Dusemund
Citations
Sep 11, 2020·Foods·Shlomit DavidUri Lesmes
May 31, 2019·Marine Drugs·Maria Dolores TorresHerminia Domínguez
Sep 29, 2020·Journal of Biomedical Materials Research. Part a·Eduardas CicinskasAleksandra A Kalitnik
Mar 12, 2020·Food Research International·Shlomit DavidUri Lesmes
Jul 21, 2021·Bioengineered·Yu-Chen LiaoJo-Shu Chang
Aug 18, 2021·Journal of Genetics and Genomics = Yi Chuan Xue Bao·Yeshi YinXin Wang