Reviewing the review: a qualitative assessment of the peer review process in surgical journals

Research Integrity and Peer Review
Catherine H DavisThomas A Aloia

Abstract

Despite rapid growth of the scientific literature, no consensus guidelines have emerged to define the optimal criteria for editors to grade submitted manuscripts. The purpose of this project was to assess the peer reviewer metrics currently used in the surgical literature to evaluate original manuscript submissions. Manuscript grading forms for 14 of the highest circulation general surgery-related journals were evaluated for content, including the type and number of quantitative and qualitative questions asked of peer reviewers. Reviewer grading forms for the seven surgical journals with the higher impact factors were compared to the seven surgical journals with lower impact factors using Fisher's exact tests. Impact factors of the studied journals ranged from 1.73 to 8.57, with a median impact factor of 4.26 in the higher group and 2.81 in the lower group. The content of the grading forms was found to vary considerably. Relatively few journals asked reviewers to grade specific components of a manuscript. Higher impact factor journal manuscript grading forms more frequently addressed statistical analysis, ethical considerations, and conflict of interest. In contrast, lower impact factor journals more commonly requested reviewer...Continue Reading

References

Mar 1, 1996·Preventive Medicine·E Frank
Jul 24, 1998·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·S van RooyenN Black
Jul 24, 1998·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·F GodleeC N Martyn
Jul 21, 2000·Advances in Physiology Education·D R Seals, H Tanaka
Jun 15, 2007·Advances in Physiology Education·Dale J BenosAlexander Zotov
Mar 25, 2010·BMJ : British Medical Journal·David MoherDouglas G Altman
Oct 18, 2011·Journal of Clinical Epidemiology·Elaine L Larson, Manuel Cortazal
Oct 2, 2014·BMC Medicine·Philip F Stahel, Ernest E Moore
Aug 15, 2015·Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery·Kevin C ChungRod J Rohrich
Feb 15, 2016·BMC Medicine·Philip F Stahel, Ernest E Moore
Jul 5, 2017·International Journal of Surgery·Riaz A AghaDouglas G Altman
Jan 24, 2018·Lancet·Peter McCullochChristopher Pennell

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Software Mentioned

SPSS

Related Concepts

Trending Feeds

COVID-19

Coronaviruses encompass a large family of viruses that cause the common cold as well as more serious diseases, such as the ongoing outbreak of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19; formally known as 2019-nCoV). Coronaviruses can spread from animals to humans; symptoms include fever, cough, shortness of breath, and breathing difficulties; in more severe cases, infection can lead to death. This feed covers recent research on COVID-19.

Blastomycosis

Blastomycosis fungal infections spread through inhaling Blastomyces dermatitidis spores. Discover the latest research on blastomycosis fungal infections here.

Nuclear Pore Complex in ALS/FTD

Alterations in nucleocytoplasmic transport, controlled by the nuclear pore complex, may be involved in the pathomechanism underlying multiple neurodegenerative diseases including Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis and Frontotemporal Dementia. Here is the latest research on the nuclear pore complex in ALS and FTD.

Applications of Molecular Barcoding

The concept of molecular barcoding is that each original DNA or RNA molecule is attached to a unique sequence barcode. Sequence reads having different barcodes represent different original molecules, while sequence reads having the same barcode are results of PCR duplication from one original molecule. Discover the latest research on molecular barcoding here.

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Chronic fatigue syndrome is a disease characterized by unexplained disabling fatigue; the pathology of which is incompletely understood. Discover the latest research on chronic fatigue syndrome here.

Evolution of Pluripotency

Pluripotency refers to the ability of a cell to develop into three primary germ cell layers of the embryo. This feed focuses on the mechanisms that underlie the evolution of pluripotency. Here is the latest research.

Position Effect Variegation

Position Effect Variagation occurs when a gene is inactivated due to its positioning near heterochromatic regions within a chromosome. Discover the latest research on Position Effect Variagation here.

STING Receptor Agonists

Stimulator of IFN genes (STING) are a group of transmembrane proteins that are involved in the induction of type I interferon that is important in the innate immune response. The stimulation of STING has been an active area of research in the treatment of cancer and infectious diseases. Here is the latest research on STING receptor agonists.

Microbicide

Microbicides are products that can be applied to vaginal or rectal mucosal surfaces with the goal of preventing, or at least significantly reducing, the transmission of sexually transmitted infections. Here is the latest research on microbicides.

Related Papers

AJR. American Journal of Roentgenology
Michael E Spieth
The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
Lisa M BrownKatie S Nason
© 2022 Meta ULC. All rights reserved