Abstract
The validated 'STARWAVe' (Short illness duration, Temperature, Age, Recession, Wheeze, Asthma, Vomiting) clinical prediction rule (CPR) uses seven variables to guide risk assessment and antimicrobial stewardship in children presenting with cough. We aimed to compare general practitioners' (GPs) risk assessments and prescribing decisions to those of STARWAVe and assess the influence of the CPR's clinical variables. Primary care. 252 GPs, currently practising in the UK. GPs were randomly assigned to view four (of a possible eight) clinical vignettes online. Each vignette depicted a child presenting with cough, who was described in terms of the seven STARWAVe variables. Systematically, we manipulated patient age (20 months vs 5 years), illness duration (3 vs 6 days), vomiting (present vs absent) and wheeze (present vs absent), holding the remaining STARWAVe variables constant. Per vignette, GPs assessed risk of hospitalisation and indicated whether they would prescribe antibiotics or not. GPs overestimated risk of hospitalisation in 9% of vignette presentations (88/1008) and underestimated it in 46% (459/1008). Despite underestimating risk, they overprescribed: 78% of prescriptions were unnecessary relative to GPs' own risk assess...Continue Reading
References
Oct 30, 1976·British Medical Journal·J G Howie
Jan 1, 1995·Medical Decision Making : an International Journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making·R M PosesR S Wigton
Aug 1, 1997·Respiratory Medicine·J MacfarlaneW Holmes
Sep 4, 1998·BMJ : British Medical Journal·C C ButlerN Stott
Jan 6, 1999·Archives of Disease in Childhood·T FaheyT Thomas
Apr 2, 1999·Pediatrics·R Mangione-SmithR H Brook
Jan 18, 2003·BMJ : British Medical Journal·Satinder KumarNicky Britten
Feb 9, 2005·BMC Family Practice·Thomas FischerEva Hummers-Pradier
Jul 23, 2005·Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care·Petur Petursson
Dec 6, 2005·Family Practice·Rogier M HopstakenGeert-Jan Dinant
Oct 20, 2007·BMJ : British Medical Journal·I PetersenA C Hayward
Aug 14, 2010·Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care·Kristin Alise JakobsenChristopher C Butler
May 24, 2012·BMJ Open·Lucy Brookes-HowellChristopher C Butler
Nov 6, 2013·The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews·Anneliese SpinksChris B Del Mar
Mar 4, 2014·The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews·Susan M SmithLorne A Becker
Oct 29, 2014·BMJ Open·Martin C GullifordLisa McDermott
Dec 17, 2014·BMC Family Practice·Patrick P DempseyJeffrey A Linder
Feb 27, 2015·Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care·Patricia J LucasJeremy Horwood
Mar 4, 2015·British Journal of Cancer·P P-C ChiangJ D Emery
May 26, 2015·Social Science & Medicine·Christie CabralJeremy Horwood
Jun 24, 2015·The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews·Roderick P VenekampMaroeska M Rovers
Sep 17, 2015·BMJ Open·Sophie L TurnbullPeter S Blair
Feb 9, 2016·The British Journal of General Practice : the Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners·Jeremy HorwoodJenny Ingram
Nov 2, 2016·The Lancet. Respiratory Medicine·Alastair D HayPeter S Blair
Feb 17, 2017·Health Psychology : Official Journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association·Miroslav SirotaOlga Kostopoulou
Jan 12, 2020·Journal of Basic and Clinical Physiology and Pharmacology·Pratama Novan Y IUNKNOWN Suharjono
Jul 2, 2020·Medical Decision Making : an International Journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making·Olga KostopoulouBrendan C Delaney