Abstract
Knowledge which links dietary fat and cholesterol to coronary heart disease (CHD) has been controversial for more than forty years. While policies advocating fat and cholesterol restriction are now deeply ingrained in affluent western societies, the scientific 'facts' on which they are supposedly based are highly contested. Applying concepts from actor-network theory and the symbolic interactionist social worlds approach, I argue that knowledge and dietary recommendations relating to cholesterol, fat and CHD are the outcome of complex social negotiations which can only be understood in their cultural, commercial and political contexts. Policies were framed in the 1960s before 'proof' of their efficacy was available. Since then, ambiguous experimental results have been shaped to support the policies. I argue that, despite its many attractive features, actor-network theory cannot adequately deal with protracted controversies. Social worlds theory provides a much more useful framework for investigating long debates in which the 'facts' remain elusive.
Citations
Nov 16, 2010·New Genetics and Society·Michelle L McGowanMarcie A Lambrix
Jun 24, 2014·Social Science & Medicine·Erica Prussing
Aug 2, 2011·Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences·Tiago Moreira, Paolo Palladino
Jul 4, 2006·Journal of the American Dietetic Association·Jose M Ordovas
Feb 21, 2009·Social Studies of Science·Jason A Delborne
Jul 28, 2011·History of the Human Sciences·Chris Hurl
Oct 8, 2005·Science, Technology & Human Values·Robert DalpeLouis Bedard
Nov 22, 2014·Public Understanding of Science·Mikko Jauho
Oct 15, 2014·Public Understanding of Science·Nina Blom Andersen
Apr 3, 2003·Qualitative Health Research·Nora Jacobson
Jan 24, 2019·Sociology of Health & Illness·Mikko Jauho
Jun 7, 2016·Social Studies of Science·Adam Isaiah Green
May 26, 2018·PloS One·Rhodri Ivor Leng
Sep 16, 2011·Food and Nutrition Bulletin·Purnima MenonTahmeed Ahmed
Apr 14, 2017·Social Studies of Science·Xaq Frohlich
Oct 5, 2020·Health & Place·Xiang Yan, Shenjing He
Jun 4, 2021·Sociology of Health & Illness·Fan-Tzu Tseng
Jul 31, 2021·Health & Place·Gavin J Andrews