Abstract
In contrast to the 20 to 30% reduction in ischemic heart disease mortality that has been demonstrated by national mortality statistics and by several randomized controlled trials, an uncritical reading of recent "natural history" studies suggests far greater improvements in the survival of symptomatic coronary patients. Although the intrinsic accuracy of such natural history studies is not questioned, attempts to compare patients from different studies and different eras may greatly overestimate the true improvement in natural history because of at least 3 biases in the selection of cases from the spectrum of diseased patients. Because of lead-time bias, patients who are diagnosed earlier live longer regardless of whether interventions are efficacious. Because of referral bias, current patients may have symptoms or anatomy that place them at a different stage of severity than patients who were chosen for earlier studies. Because of incidence-prevalence bias, prevalence studies will be over-represented with survivors of previous incidence cohorts who have slower-progressing disease. We suggest that all natural history studies be carefully scrutinized for such biases before they are compared with each other.
References
May 1, 1979·The American Journal of Cardiology·S E EpsteinD R Rosing
Sep 27, 1975·British Medical Journal
Nov 1, 1978·The American Journal of Cardiology·G M LawrieD W Chapman
Jan 1, 1979·Journal of Chronic Diseases·D L Sackett
Dec 1, 1979·Circulation·P J HarrisR A Rosati
Jul 1, 1978·Progress in Cardiovascular Diseases·W L ProudfitF M Sones
Jan 1, 1978·Journal of Chronic Diseases·R CooperD Garside
Jan 1, 1975·Circulation·G W Burggraf, J O Parker
Feb 1, 1974·The American Journal of Cardiology·J S WebsterG Rincon
Mar 1, 1974·Circulation·J O HumphriesE E Page
May 17, 1971·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·J J McNamaraR T Cutting
Jun 1, 1981·Circulation·K DetreT Takaro
Apr 2, 1981·The New England Journal of Medicine·UNKNOWN Norwegian Multicenter Study Group
May 1, 1982·Circulation·L GoldmanA Loscalzo
Nov 5, 1981·The New England Journal of Medicine·P J PodridB Lown
Feb 1, 1981·The American Journal of Cardiology·P F CohnC Waternaux
Jul 18, 1953·Journal of the American Medical Association·W F ENOSJ BEYER
Citations
Apr 22, 2014·PharmacoEconomics·Laura T BurgersJohan L Severens
Oct 1, 1985·British Heart Journal·D G Julian
Mar 22, 1984·The New England Journal of Medicine·UNKNOWN CASS Principal Investigators and Their Associates
Apr 5, 2007·British Journal of Cancer·D P Cronin-FentonH T Sørensen
Feb 15, 1988·Hospital Practice·L Goldman
Jul 1, 1986·Journal of General Internal Medicine·L Goldman, T H Lee