Who calls the shots? The ethics of adolescentself-consent for HPV vaccination

Journal of Medical Ethics
Suchi Agrawal, Stephanie R Morain

Abstract

While the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine is medically indicated to reduce the risk of genital warts and certain types of cancer, rates of HPV vaccination repeatedly fall short of public health goals. Individual-level factors contributing to low vaccination rates are well documented. However, system-level barriers, particularly the need for parental consent, have been less explored. To date, there is no legal or ethical consensus in the USA regarding whether adolescents might permissibly self-consent to the HPV vaccine. Consequently, there is considerable variability in medical practice at the provider and state level. In this essay, we explore the ethical acceptability of vaccinating adolescents for HPV without parental consent. We argue that the same ethical considerations that justify permitting minors to consent to treatment for sexual and reproductive health care-namely, public health benefit and adolescents' developing autonomy-similarly justify permitting minors to consent to HPV vaccination. Based on this analysis, we conclude that allowing adolescents to self-consent to the HPV vaccine is ethically justifiable and should be reflected in US state policies.

References

Jan 1, 1985·Medical Decision Making : an International Journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making·P E Politser
Jun 11, 2003·Journal of Medical Ethics·V English, A Sommerville
Aug 10, 2004·The Journal of Adolescent Health : Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine·Carol FordGarry Sigman
Aug 20, 2005·The Journal of Adolescent Health : Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine·Gregory D ZimetRose M Mays
Apr 1, 2006·Journal of Medical Ethics·D S Wendler
Jan 19, 2008·Pediatrics·Abigail EnglishUNKNOWN Working Group on Legislation, Vaccination, and Adolescent Health
May 26, 2009·The Journal of Adolescent Health : Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine·Carol A FordAmy J Stinnett
May 29, 2009·Current Opinion in Pediatrics·Elise D Berlan, Terrill Bravender
Jan 1, 2011·Case Reports in Pediatrics·Amit Agrawal, Rashmi Agrawal
Nov 3, 2012·The Virtual Mentor : VM·Donna T ChenDaniel M Becker
Apr 24, 2013·The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy·Laurence Steinberg
Jan 7, 2015·JAMA : the Journal of the American Medical Association·Ronald BayerRobert Klitzman
Dec 1, 2015·Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics·Richard Griffith
Jun 11, 2016·American Journal of Public Health·Lisa M LeeBruce Jennings

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Citations

Dec 21, 2019·Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics·Neisha SundaramClarence C Tam
Jan 24, 2021·The Journal of Pediatrics·Gregory D ZimetAbigail English
Sep 3, 2021·Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics·Chiara CadedduChiara de Waure

❮ Previous
Next ❯

Related Concepts

Related Feeds

Cancer Vaccines

Cancer vaccines are vaccines that either treat existing cancer or prevent development of a cancer.